Brown FOR SURE.
Better location, more course offerings, the opportunity to take classes at RISD, slightly larger so you will meet more people..... amazing liberal, intellectual atmosphere, ivy league prestige.
That being said, Brown is the perfect school for some people (like me) but I guess others think it gives students too much independence in picking their courses, creating majors, etc. If you think you'd like to be considered independent and mature enough to design your own education and participate in a thriving intellectual and extremely diverse/eclectic environment, then Brown is for you.
Btw, I'm a Brown 2012er
