Dartmouth has incredible recruiting for its size, probably right behind HYPW in the ivy league. Duke does really well too, especially at MS.
This stuff isn't a secret, do some research. It's a well known fact that Chicago does not do that well at all for NYC BB's; most end up in Chicago.
Ibankingoasis.com is an excellent resource for this kind of stuff and the people that post there actual work on wall street, so take their word for it.
heres one thread about Uchicago
Econ at the University of Chicago?? | WallStreetOasis.com
use the search engine, there is plenty of stuff there.