We're in the same situation here. DS took the ACT cold end of 10th grade and scored 34. His PSAT is 201 (maybe squeak in as commended?) but we're in CA so no way Semi. He's not going to take SAT 1, but he is retaking ACT because his writing was 9 and kids generally improve their scores.
If you decide to retake, here's what I wished we had done: You can order a copy of her test questions and answers. That way she can concentrate on areas where she missed questions.
ACT Score Information: Requesting a Copy of Your Test Questions and Answers