View Single Post
Old 11-25-2006, 01:03 PM   #61
curmudgeon
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Threads: 173
Posts: 5,790
Not so fast. That ain't all you said, now is it?
Quote:
The reality of $50,000 per year will deflate this bubble rather quickly. In reality there are only about 20 schools that will produce the vast majority of all the Rhodes, Marshalls, foreign Service officers, investment bankers, top 25 big firm lawyers, cia agents, NIH grant winners, doctors etc. These 20 schools have an important function in developing our national leadership and identifying true talent and are actually worth the price.(This means I assume that the others aren't worth the price?)

Beyond those 20, college becomes a commodity where one could substitute any of one hundred fifty names for any other 150. It is here that the bubble will hit since it is pure hype that is inflating the applications to this group. Amazingly, the key to the hype seems to be raising tuition to near the level of the top 20 so that anxiety prone parents think the commodity schools are worth the exhorbitant price. The extra tuition is used for a relatively small amount of merit aid which is pursued by many that further fuels the fire. Well, people are seeing thtough this now and in an era where defined benefit pensions are being eliminated and health care is going to Mars, parents, particularly the ones paying the full $45,000 freight, will just say no. This will actually be to the benefit of the public college and community college systems as they are on the cusp of an era of vast improvement.
Stick to your guns. Have some staying power. Don't back up from your words now. You'll look like a sand crab on meth.

Do you believe this or do you not? Seems to me you diss everything but twenty schools. Which twenty and why won't you tell us? I assume it does not include G'town, does it?


How is this anything but an insult?

Quote:
Beyond those 20, college becomes a commodity where one could substitute any of one hundred fifty names for any other 150.
So Colgate is Southern Illinois State, U of Texas is Texas State and Rutgers is Utah Tech? Is that about it? Outside of your top twenty , who cares?

Last edited by curmudgeon : 11-25-2006 at 01:11 PM.
curmudgeon is offline