Here's the list from one of my 'admitted student questionnaires'
- Academic Reputation
- Availability of majors of interst to you
- Availability of special academic programs (independent study, honors programs, etc.)
- Personal attention to students
- Quality of academic facilities (library, labs, etc.)
- Availability of recreational facilities on campus
- Quality of on-campus housing
- Surroundings (neighborhood, town or city)
- Attractiveness of campus
- Cost to your family -- how much you and your family would have to pay after grants and scholarships (if any) are subractd from your total college costs
- Quality of social life
- Access to off-campus cultural and recreational opportunities
- Opportunities to participate in extracurricular activities
- Chance to be students with different backgrounds
- Quality of faculty
- Athletic programs in which you would like to participate
I think that pretty much covers it. Considering those criteria will definitely help you narrow down your choices. While PR's Best X Colleges is relies heavily on anecdotal perspectives, I found it very useful when I was looking for colleges. To figure out if you're a good fit academically, check out the college's SAT score range. Though it should not entirely dictate to which colleges you apply, that information is a good guide to understanding at which colleges you have a shot, and at which ones you really don't. I'm sorry people, holistic admissions does not relegate SAT scores to the bottom of the 'applicant criteria' list.
Overall, I found those college guides like Fiske, PR's Best 381 Colleges, Insider's guide, to be all very helpful.