| perspective from berkeley business student came across this board while distracting myself from a paper. I am a current berkeley business major who was considering going to marshall. Being in a similar situation, I advise you take a moment to figure out what your career goals are, what you value in peers, and the learning environment you prefer (it's early but important).
Berkeley (Haas)
Pros:
- Great accounting and finance programs
- nicest building on campus (we have a mini-campus as opposed to one building or floor)
- strong alumni networks in Bay Area, SoCal, and East Coast
- all elite firms recruit at Berkeley (bulge bracket banks, Big 4 accounting, and McKinsey/Bain/BCG)
- SF is financial hub of West Coast and Silicon Valley is the tech/venture capital/biotech heartland of U.S.
- Classwork is group-project driven and students are very driven
Con:
- you apply after two years, so it's a gamble
- two year program rushes you through courses
- faculty is a mixed-bag
- huge intro classes (200+ in intro accounting, econ, and finance)
- students are hyper-competitive and grades/gpa > learning
- MBA program gets preference, undergrad program not paid attention to much
- it lowered in Businessweek rankings this year and from what I see, the quality is going down slightly
USC (Marshall)
Pro:
- 4 year program so you have strong business foundation
- Great accounting program
- Great alumni network, though mostly in SoCal
- Smaller classes I assume
- from what I remember, the technology was really up-to-date and the building itself was nice
- great international and media-related tracks (I got into their cinema-television business track, but I felt like it was too restrictive)
Cons:
- USC has no brand name outside of SoCal (unless it's in the context of sports) so if you want to work on East Coast, you have a higher chance coming from Haas (although I have a family friend working at Goldman in NY who went to SC)
- Maybe I'm generalizing, but the caliber of students you're going to meet are nowhere near the ones you'll meet at Berkeley/Haas
- For business jobs in LA-area, accounting and consulting are strong but finance is poor (UBS LA is dying, Goldman LA is consolidating to SF, and only Credit Suisse LA has any pull). Most firms recruit from UCLA, Caltech, and Claremont/Pomona - not really USC.
Again, it's best to talk to students in programs at the school to get a better idea. |