They look very closely at your passions. They want to see dedication (so laundry lists of ECs are totally out!) and some personal drive because they know that dedicated, driven people are more likely to accomplish their goals and what needs to be done. Colgate students have a strong record of accomplishing successful events on campus and in their own lives. Colgate literally runs on students with the faculty and staff standing behind them rooting them on to wherever they want to go.
No, you don't need to be a big fan of spots to enjoy Colgate. The school spirit by itself is so infectious. Even when hockey season is over in the winter, there are still campus traditions going on to keep the spirit up. Every time I walked around the campus and up and down the hill, I just looked at the scenery and think how LUCKY I was to be at Colgate. Colgate is more than just sports

It's about a community supporting itself- so many students show up for our semester-end DanceFest, pep rallies, major annual events, etc. I'm serious- the library and COOP (campus center) are deserted during those times.