I think several of the schools on your list are reaches. I would panic just yet because you do seem like you have athletic talent and some decent involvement in school. I'd choose maybe 2-4 of the schools on your list to apply to as reaches and then find some other schools to be safety's and targets.
Drexel, Hofstra, and Fordham might be some good target schools for you, but I would call the rest a reach. Try to think of some safety's and DEFINITELY get in touch with your guidance counselor. Good luck
Check out my post?? I'm looking for some feedback
http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/...-into-unc.html