i think legacies count equally, especially strong ones for both in and out of state, however, i agree with menehune that even with "equal" legacies, the issue of in vs. out of state is of major importance. it is SIGNIFICANTLY HARDER for OOS-ers to gain admission. our info session openly spoke of this difference in terms of one's stats, etc. so if 2 applicants are legacy, the OOS one will have much harder requirements for entrance. they don't call it a "Public Ivy" for nothing!