Welcome to College Confidential!

The leading college-bound community on the web

Sign Up For Free

Join for FREE, and start talking with other members, weighing in on community discussions, and more.

Also, by registering and logging in you'll see fewer ads and pesky welcome messages (like this one!)

As a CC member, you can:

  • Reply to threads, and start your own.
  • Post reviews of your campus visits.
  • Find hundreds of pages of informative articles.
  • Search from over 3 million scholarships.

Harvey Mudd CompSci Majors are 55% Female

Roger_DooleyRoger_Dooley Founder Posts: 106,390 Senior Member
edited January 6 in Harvey Mudd College
Giant tech companies like Google and Facebook have struggled to achieve any kind of gender balance in their technical staff, in part because computer science programs at top universities skew heavily male. Most of these schools talk about outreach to female students and other measures, but one has actually done something about it. Harvey Mudd's CompSci majors are now 55% female, according to this article in the LA Times by Rosanna Xia:

That number compares to a mere 10% ten years ago and a current national average of 16%. The article describes a host of changes at Harvey Mudd, including a curriculum revamp and recruitment of new profs.

There's a lesson here beyond gender parity, too. The curriculum changes seem to have produced a different attitude toward CompSci among the entire student body:
"The introductory course is now one of the most popular across the Claremont campuses. More than 40% of non-computer science majors, hooked after the first class, go on to take at least two more programming courses."

[Image credit: LA Times]

Replies to: Harvey Mudd CompSci Majors are 55% Female

  • ColoradomamaColoradomama Registered User Posts: 428 Member
    However "popular" courses do not make a strong computer scientist. Harvey Mudd has some female students rejected for PhD programs in CS because they are on the light side for a CS degree. Harvey Mudd is more liberal artsy and very hard on grading too. So Harvey Mudd graduates, girls or boys, are often disappointed and get rejected for PhD programs at UW Seattle, MIT, and Berkeley , the top PhD programs in the world for CS. Compare the CS programs at Georgia Tech and Harvey Mudd College and you will see that Harvey Mudd is not as strong.
  • sbballersbballer Registered User Posts: 191 Junior Member
  • ucbalumnusucbalumnus Registered User Posts: 56,599 Senior Member
    Re: #4

    That article also mentions that "women comprise just 30 percent of computer science majors at Stanford". Meaning that even more men than women choose to major in CS, although 30% is higher than the national percentage of 18%.
  • ColoradomamaColoradomama Registered User Posts: 428 Member
    Harvey Mudd College needs to have a class about Tina Huang, MIT class of 1993's lawsuit against Twitter.
    And then ask themselves is a tiny technical school , smaller than a high school making a dent? NO. UCLA, Berkeley, are the big guns out there for computer sciences, with UC San Diego, San Jose State, Cal Poly in both locations and UC Davis educating the BULK of CS majors along with MIT, and UIUC and UT Austin and Georgia Tech, as well as UW Seattle. What Harvey Mudd says or does is a blip on the graph and changes nothing.
    Look at Facebook carefully and ask yourself why would technical women just say NO? Its run by two Harvard econ majors with banking knowledge who write books to tell younger women to LEAN IN while they rake in the dough! PLEASE Harvey Mudd understand that taking more and more girls only makes the problem more compelling as these girls land at Twitter and are the only girl in the room and do not know how to talk to boys. We need a lot more education across gender boundaries NOW at all schools including Harvey Mudd College. We need to understand male environments if we are to work in one, so gender balancing may not really help at all. How many Mudders take the highest jobs of the land in CS? The $200,000 plus jobs teaching discrete math at Georgia Tech or Any very high up Silicon Valley job? Harvey Mudd education or MIT does not matter, getting along with men is the only skill that matters in Silicon Valley right now. LIGHTEN UP on hard grading and teach girls to talk and get along with boys, whatever it takes. Ask the likes of Carley Fiorina and other female high tech formers to WRITE THE CLASS. OK, choose a more successful manager we have a lot now. Academics need to GET IN THE FIELD, aka Facebook and Twitter and then teach girls how to cope. Off soap box.

  • ColoradomamaColoradomama Registered User Posts: 428 Member
    Back on Soap Box: Its not about which school on learns CS . look at who makes big dollars in Silicon Valley. They are men who often dropped out of Carnegie Mellon, I know three at least! . They are men who are freshman at Georgia Tech and work all night long on start ups . they are men who graduated Stanford, and coded on the side since their days at a Palo Alto high school, OR They are Harvard and Warton B school grads, (Men plus the Lean in Girl) who run the place. Women need a class about how to do it. They do not need sugar coating classes suitable for Claremont McKenna kiddos! They do not need to be given a line of goods by academics who want so badly the numbers to improve. Women in high tech need both a backbone and they need some help about how to deal with a roomful of men. May I suggest good perfume and knowledge of the meeting content and goals both? A solid technical grasp and a sense of humor so you can roll with sexual inuendo? A balancing hobby like YOGA and impecable standards, as sleeping to the top may not work anymore?! And a public speaking class to avoid a whining female voice? The biggest inhibitor to female success is lack of knowledge of how the system works. We have written books in the 1970s on this, have we forgotten all we learned?
  • intparentintparent Registered User Posts: 26,447 Senior Member
    Yeah, I wondered about the CMC comment, too. My kid has taken a few classes there (mostly lit classes, which is her secondary concentration) and has found them challenging and interesting.
  • AgentXJPAgentXJP Registered User Posts: 57 Junior Member
    edited January 7
    And conservatives and right-wingers everywhere wept. How dare those women!
Sign In or Register to comment.