Probably best to start a new thread then tack onto one that is 3 yrs old. Most of those individuals are long gone from here.
The general consensus when this topic has been discussed in the past is that Eagle Scouts gets you about as many points as varsity team captain. I think for some, they outgrow scouting in h.s. when they have a wider variety or sports or ECA's to participate in. Your whole candidate score is the sum total of all things you have accomplished in h.s.. No one activity is a magical key to an appointment and there are various combinations of activities one might be involved with.