mwmtmom, perhaps I used the wrong word when I said "vibe."

But it's difficult to describe in words that thing that makes a school want one kid and another reject him or her. It can't be ONLY talent and accomplishment, as I think we would all acknowledge that many more talented and accomplished kids audition for each and very respected MT program each year. If talent and accomplishment were the whole story, then every good program would accept the same kids. But that doesn't always happen. In fact, I don't think it even usually happens. On this list and elsewhere, we hear about kids who are accepted to some places and not others, and it seems to make no sense from the outside. But it *does* make sense to the adjudicators who are making the decisions. *They* know what they are looking for and what kids are likely to best fit into their program and their approach. As a result (and teachers anywhere will tell you this to back me up), each and every class of students (whether in elementary school or high school or college!) has a certain personality and feeling. This is a longwinded way of saying that, like all schools, Michigan knows what it's looking for and when they see it, they accept the kid and when they don't, that kid is not accepted. However, that kid may well fit perfectly with the "vibe/sensibility/etc" at another great school and be accepted there. Sorry for any confusion! I sure didn't mean to offend anyone!