It's good to hear that so many of you overcame some bad grades and moved on to graduation. Just to clarify, D did not chose these two girls. She just chose one of the last vacant spots available on campus since she didn't want to live in the local motel. No names or relationships were involved in the choosing of this room.
The girls do not seem to be into the party scene because they are both active the the campus Christian clubs, which frown on that kind of thing. I don't know if there are any LD issues involved. I suspect they just goof off a lot. They are both from far away and one of them plans to bring her horse with her next year and board it nearby so she can ride more. What are those parents thinking??
I think it could work if these two girls come back. I'm just not sure they will get to. As someone already stated, the fact that finals are the deciding factor is not a good sign.