A PM that was sent to me has had all identifying information removed.
Quote:
I like both schools, and they are financially equal. Can you please advise me which school will be better for admission to med school? Do the USNWR rankings matter to MD admission committees?
School X is ranked somewhat higher than School Y. In a hypothetical scenario, which GPA is better: 4.0 from X,or a 3.8 from Y?
|
1.) The USN rankings do not seem to matter much, since some schools that come from similar rankings seem to have quite different results, and some lower-ranked schools seem to have better results, on average.
2.) While I think it's possible that one school could, on average, have a lower admitted-student-GPA (in which case a 3.6 from there would trump a 3.8 from someplace else), it's impossible for me to say which school. It is not necessarily the higher-ranked one.
3.) 0.2 GPA points seems a little on the high end to me, in any case. I don't think many pairs of schools will demonstrate this large a gap.
4.) This gap in any case would probably disappear if one of the GPA's in question was a 4.0. It's hard to trump a 4.0.
5.) While gaps are sometimes attributable to MCAT scores, they are sometimes not. Furthermore, they might be attributable to EC's and interview skills -- there's no way for us to know.