Welcome to College Confidential!

The leading college-bound community on the web

Sign Up For Free

Join for FREE, and start talking with other members, weighing in on community polls, and more.

Also, by registering and logging in you'll see fewer ads and pesky welcome messages (like this one!)

As a CC member, you can:

College Confidential’s “Dean,” Sally Rubenstone, put together 25 of her best tips. So far, the "25 Tips from the Dean" eBook has helped more than 10K students choose a college, get in, and pay for it. Get your free copy: http://goo.gl/9zDJTM

Hard Grammar Question!

Echelon32Echelon32 Posts: 759Registered User Member
edited November 2007 in SAT Preparation
Or at least CB designates this a 5...

Twice as many bird species inhabit Ecuador as in North America.
(A) as in
(B) as inhabit
(C) instead of in
(D) when compared to
(E) than

Correct answer is (B), why is this the case?
Also, whenever you use "twice as many....." is it true that you never use "than"?
I put (D) lol.
Post edited by Echelon32 on

Replies to: Hard Grammar Question!

  • tongchen1226tongchen1226 Posts: 698Registered User Member
    answer definitely has "as" in it. i was going to choose A. i guess i want some explanation as well...
  • Python212Python212 Posts: 87Registered User Junior Member
    Hehe, I just went over this question two days ago. Definitely the weirdest writing question I've seen.
  • 8parks118parks11 Posts: 400Registered User Member
    inhabit has the definition of "living in" so using "as (inhabit) in" would be incorrect (redundant.. living in in).
  • Little_DuckLittle_Duck Posts: 982Registered User Member
    I said B before looking at the answer. Sometimes it's hard to just say it yourself to see if it sounds right when the questions are worded like this.

    The other ones really don't make sense, B made the most sense to me.
  • VorfieldVorfield Posts: 53Registered User Junior Member
    Parallel construction
  • lotf629lotf629 Posts: 703Registered User Member
    This *is* a hard question. Let me give you the short version.

    First of all, whenever we use one "as," we need a second "as." You can't say "I'm twice AS fast WHEN COMPARED TO him," right?

    So our only choices are A and B, as tongchen said.

    Now, "as. . . as" is the same kind of construction as "either. . . or" and "neither. . . nor." (They're all correlative conjunctions.) You guys remember how either/or and neither/nor always need parallel constructions? It's wrong to say "He NEITHER went to the circus NOR to the zoo," because "went to the circus" does not match "to the zoo." You'd have to say, "He went NEITHER to the circus NOR to the zoo."

    The same rule applies here.

    A is not parallel. What's more, there's no earthly use for "in" in this sentence.

    B is parallel. "inhabit Ecuador" matches "inhabit North America."

    I could go on and on 'cause it really is a weird question, but I think that's the shortest and simplest explanation.
  • AmuAmu Posts: 224Registered User Junior Member
    lotf629's explanation is excellent. This is a good question to learn from.
Sign In or Register to comment.