The better the grades, the more competitive you are.
Serenityhope, grades alone cannot help you nor it can predict any future success alone. There are people with 4.0s rejected before. On the NYU undergraduate admissions website, they said they are looking for people who do not simply could do the work but express themselves as people that deserve to go there.
I got to admit this, but most admission officers look for people who are likely to be a leader some day after they graduate and become great alumni that will give back to the university. That's why most colleges like leadership positions. It shows you are capable as a leader. There are also many things such as being capable of taking a hard courseload. It's better to have high grades in hard courses than high grades in easy courses or decent grades in hard courses.
No one can tell if your essay is great. One person may think it is great, one may think it is horrible. Like the essays in SAT Is, they will be more than one person reviewing your application.
I worked in the Fordham admissions office a while ago doing freshman admissions. Some of the admissions officers are actually professors of sociology or psychology. Generally they separate by region to read the application. They generally check everything in the application first and the last being your grades. I remember them giving out numerical scores (similar to the 1-12 scores for the essays on the SATs) for each application. The lowest scores of course end up well in the rejected pile while the remainder would be re-read and graded again and again until they meet their the number of applicants they would like to accept. As for me, well I send the rejection letters... :cough cough:
I don't know if the admissions process is the same in NYU but that's in Fordham.
I recommend exploring the NYU admissions website. They somewhat provide tips to you on who are they looking for. Here are some links I think that are important:
General requirements:
http://admissions.nyu.edu/applying.f...uirements.html
What they say about their transfer admissions process:
http://admissions.nyu.edu/applying.f...admission.html
Paper Application Tips:
http://admissions.nyu.edu/applying.f....do.paper.html
Online Application Tips:
http://admissions.nyu.edu/applying.f...do.online.html
By the way, are you applying for transfer 2008? The deadline is today!