Scoronado - University of Arizona - Epinions.com
A review, albeit a bit old. Has negatives and positives, and seems fairly unbiased.
I actually chose Coronado to live in (call me stupid, whatever). From the people similar to me that I've talked to, it isn't really as bad as some people would want you to believe.
I wanted a big dorm, as the social aspect is something I really wanted. I know it's not the newest, and doesn't have the "best" (very subjective term) reputation, but it seemed to have everything I was looking for.
My eventual decision came when I told myself - It isn't a lifetime commitment. It's 9 months. Good or bad, I'll walk away with something.
(I'm speaking from a guy's point of view. I'm sure a girl has different criteria for their living quarters.)