You won't find much love on this site, since most on CC lean East Coast in school research. I know several young men that attend the school, and all love it. Of the graduates, all got jobs or into medical school. All grew to very ambitious, articulate young men. If you haven't done an overnight, try to do one ASAP- and not just honors weekend. Sit in classes to get a feel for the academics. deally sit in something that is in your intended major and then something like religion, enduring questions or rhetoric to see how you "fit" in a small classroom.
My DS will hopefully be joining you at Wabash in the class of 16, but we have a very long way to go from this point.