Welcome to College Confidential!

The leading college-bound community on the web

Sign Up For Free

Join for FREE, and start talking with other members, weighing in on community discussions, and more.

Also, by registering and logging in you'll see fewer ads and pesky welcome messages (like this one!)

As a CC member, you can:

  • Reply to threads, and start your own.
  • Post reviews of your campus visits.
  • Find hundreds of pages of informative articles.
  • Search from over 3 million scholarships.

Lesson Learned for Getting Into Ivy League School

trackmbe3trackmbe3 Registered User Posts: 626 Member
The lesson learned I want to pass on for next years top applicants who aspire to get into one of the 8 Ivy League schools is to apply Early Decision. I can't stress this enough. I recognize this might not be possible for some due to financial concerns, but if your family can afford it or if the Net Price Calculator indicates you will receive enough need based aid for it to be affordable for you to attend, then Early Decision will substantially increase your odds of admission. Anecdotally I know of a few valedictorians and salutatorians this year (with stellar credentials including standardized test scores and research and extracurricular activities) who wanted badly to get into an Ivy League school but were uncertain which one, so they applied to Regular Decision to several Ivy League schools, only to be disappointed at being denied admisson at each on. And yet I know several lesser credentialed applicants who applied Early Decison to an Ivy League school and several of them got accepted or guaranteed transfer for sophomore year.

Replies to: Lesson Learned for Getting Into Ivy League School

  • CU123CU123 Registered User Posts: 2,720 Senior Member
    edited August 2017
    @Lindagaf SCEA doesn't help one bit, but ED helps quite a bit. Look at the websites for schools that use ED and there stats (Penn even says outright ED helps you get in), IOW not HYPS. The difference between ED and RD is very significant. The OP is correct, you're mixing up SCEA with ED.
  • LindagafLindagaf Registered User Posts: 8,259 Senior Member
    edited August 2017
    @CU123 , I said it isn't as big an advantage as people think it is. If you aren't extremely well-qualified, you aren't getting in just by applying early. Not mixing things up. Yes, the difference can be significant for well -qualified applicants, so perhaps I should stress the well-qualified aspect.
  • CU123CU123 Registered User Posts: 2,720 Senior Member
    edited August 2017
    True no one with sub 30 ACT scores are getting in because of ED however so many students with GPA3.8-4.0/ACT 32-36 are getting denied at all there reach schools because the a) wasted there early admission on SCEA and got deferred to RD b) applied RD everywhere else. If something doesn't really stick out in your app giving you high confidence in getting accepted SCEA, you should apply RD to SCEA schools. If you have a very close second choice school that is ED, I would go for ED to that school to maximize your chances. UChicago is an extreme example of this, RD was 2% for 2017 and ED was approaching 30% (while not announced the math for this wasn't too hard). This is brought about by the adcoms having 60% of the admitted class that lamenting the fact that they didn't get into HYPS, with ED they reverse that.
  • CariñoCariño Registered User Posts: 224 Junior Member
    Sorry @Lindagaf, but OP and @CU123 are totally right. There is an indisputable advantage in applying SCEA and ED.
    And I totally disagree with the idea that the poll of applicants are stronger for those applications; on the opposite, there are many less qualified students that apply early to see if the luck is with them. Just to get the shot. At least it is what I saw in my daughter's school. 4 accepted in Harvard (all SCEA), 4 in Yale (3 SCEA), 6 in UChicago (1 EA and 4 ED), 5 UPenn (4 ED), 2 MIT (both EA)...And many many good students, with even better qualifications (and hooks) were waitlisted and rejected in RD from those schools. For those schools yield is super important. And by applying EA or ED, the students show that that university is their favorite.. obviously that is what colleges want: the greatest number of accepted students attending in the fall.
  • Sportsman88Sportsman88 Registered User Posts: 1,581 Senior Member
    OP, this is too broad and ancedotal to be valid. Were you accepted to Penn ED? Yes, Penn is blunt that ED gives a boost. That can't be generalized to other schools that offer ED. Harvard, Princeton, and Yale offer SCEA, not ED. Not sure about the other Ivies.

    SCEA does not offer a boost and can hurt because the application pool is stronger. Higher admit rates from SCEA come from athletes with prereads, legacies, and a pool of the top of the top applicants.

    Each school is different. Each application is different. It's difficult to say why one student was accepted and one was not when stats are relatively equal.

  • AsianArnoldAsianArnold Registered User Posts: 6 New Member
    Would coming from a disadvantaged, low-income mostly minority city be considered a hook? For example, I'm currently the Valedictorian with a very solid academic record, extracurriculars, and background; I live in Bridgeport, CT (one of the worst cities in the U.S.). I also don't think many kids from bad cities in CT who are really qualified will apply; will I have an edge?
  • CU123CU123 Registered User Posts: 2,720 Senior Member
    Depends, it could be if your overall situation showed you had few advantages in your life compared to other applicants, but you made the most of them.
  • AsianArnoldAsianArnold Registered User Posts: 6 New Member
    Thanks for your insight! However, generally speaking, colleges, such as Yale for example, in their SCEA round, they are still looking for applicants from different socioeconomic backgrounds, correct?
  • CALSmomCALSmom Registered User Posts: 691 Member
    edited August 2017
    Cornell's C/O 2020 stats showed that ED odds were definitely better than RD:

    ED Applicants: 4,882 / Admits: 1,340 (27.4%)
    RD Applicants: 40,083 / Admits: 4,997 (12.5%)

    6.6% of total admits were recruited athletes and not all were admitted via ED.

    For Cornell C/O 2021 the ED rate was 25.6% and RD 12.5%

    I'd agree with OP that ED chances are higher but one must be really sure about the school, which in the case of choosing an Ivy is not that difficult as each one is very distinct...a student will know which one is the best fit for them.
  • Kayak24Kayak24 Registered User Posts: 474 Member
    Reviving this thread because I’m interested in more opinions...Does ED give a significant boost?

    @tdy123 , you raise a good point about there being only 15,000 freshmen slots in all IVYs combined, but there are a lot of Vals and Sals with their sights set on other schools such as their state flagship or esteemed non-Ivy colleges such as Stanford, MIT, UChicago and then places like ND, Tufts, Vanderbilt, JHU, Duke, etc. for various reasons. I saw one poster make a claim that essentially these colleges are vying for those tippy top students (high standardized test scorers included) to keep up their own numbers game. Food for thought.
  • HS studentHS student Registered User Posts: 173 Junior Member
    edited December 2017
    Pardon my naivety, but what is Early Decision? I recall reading somewhere that as early as the class of 2022 can apply for colleges if they are certain of where they wish to go. Is this what Early Decision is? I would interested in knowing whether or not Early Decision applicants are given greater priority, as the above commenter mentioned, as well.
  • HS studentHS student Registered User Posts: 173 Junior Member
    I'm sorry, when I read about the class of 2022, it was referring to the college class of 2022. I was rather confused on this topic. I apologize.
  • ninakatarinaninakatarina Registered User Posts: 1,337 Senior Member
    Colleges have (potentially) several rounds of application deadlines, HS Student.

    Colleges can have 'rolling' deadlines, which means they start accepting applications in August and accept/reject on a flow basis until they have their full class.

    Colleges can have Early Action (EA), Early Decision (ED), Early Decision II (ED2) or Single Choice Early Action (SCEA). Early Action deadlines are typically between October 31-November 15th of your high school senior year, and they promise a non-binding decision by mid December (they tell you if you're accepted but you don't have to tell them if you're going until May 1). Early Decision deadlines are around the same time, but you may only apply to one school ED and if you are accepted you are contractually obligated to go. ED2 deadlines are a little later, they will inform you in late January/February. SCEA is used by the tippy-top schools (Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Stanford, MIT) - it's a non-binding early decision, but you can only apply to one of the tippy-top schools SCEA.

    There's a big argument over whether it's actually easier to get in during the SCEA/ED round. Those rounds have a higher total acceptance rate than the regular deadline, however in those rounds you're competing with the athletes and super legacies so you might have a lower acceptance chance.

    ED is dangerous if you're depending on financial aid to afford college, since it's a contract to attend no matter what the college offers you in aid.
Sign In or Register to comment.