I'm applying RD to Amherst this year (can't do ED for various reasons, even though it's my top choice) and I'm trying to figure out whether or not to submit my SAT and ACT, or just the ACT score. The only reason I'm asking is that my school gives us two GC's (I don't know why they do this), and (of course) both are telling me to do opposite things.
These are my scores -
ACT Composite 34
English 35 (Essay 11), Math 35, Reading 32, Science 32
SAT Subject Tests:
Math II: 750
World Hist: 800
U.S. Hist: 800
All other things (grades, ECs, etc.) aside, should I submit both or will my SAT hurt me? The one GC says that my math SAT will hurt me, so I should just use my SAT IIs and my ACT. The other says that's a stupid idea, and that it'll hurt me worse to only submit the ACT. Any thoughts?