Welcome to College Confidential!

The leading college-bound community on the web

Sign Up For Free

Join for FREE, and start talking with other members, weighing in on community discussions, and more.

Also, by registering and logging in you'll see fewer ads and pesky welcome messages (like this one!)

As a CC member, you can:

  • Reply to threads, and start your own.
  • Post reviews of your campus visits.
  • Find hundreds of pages of informative articles.
  • Search from over 3 million scholarships.

How advantageous is it to apply to Brown ED as opposed to RD?

ap012199ap012199 Registered User Posts: 1,624 Senior Member
So I just toured Brown today for the second time and fell in love with it even more! I just feel like I'm the type of person who would fit perfectly into Providence and would utilize the open curriculum to its fullest extent. I love the vibe and the students there too. The class offerings are amazing to say the least. I've really been considering going ED to Brown; exactly how much will this help my chances? I know that RD acceptance rate is ~7% and ED is 20%, but people say that it's solely because of legacy and athlete students. I feel like they admit more during ED too because the student has to go to Brown if accepted. Is this true??

Also, if I don't get into Brown ED, I'll be applying to Harvard RD with legacy. They still factor legacy in the RD round right? I know it's less than SCEA though.

So would it be worth it to apply ED to Brown?

Replies to: How advantageous is it to apply to Brown ED as opposed to RD?

  • ithinkuracontraithinkuracontra Registered User Posts: 50 Junior Member
    You are pretty much in the same exact situation I am in! I am absolutely in love with Brown for all the reasons you described, and I want to apply ED, but I'm still kind of wary of the financial commitment. I'm also going to apply RD to Harvard with legacy if Brown doesn't work out.. But my heart really isn't in that.

    Honestly, I really do think applying Early Decision (without being a legacy/athlete) says a lot to the admissions committee about your commitment and honest love for Brown as an individual school. I do think it adds something extra to your application. Also, the admissions dept. knows that they can choose many strong applicants to "lock them in." Those students aren't being distracted by other prestigious universities since they are bound to the contract, leaving their yield to be way better.

    Personally, I'd like to believe it'll help my chances. And if it makes you feel any better, my friend's dad is the dean of undergrad students at a highly selective university, and he gave me the advice to surely apply to Brown early decision if that is where my heart is set. Based on his experience with early decision at his school, he believes it's a better option for me than RD.

    I hope that helps?? (Though I didn't give you any stats or anything, haha). Good luck with your decisions! And maybe we could end up as classmates some day :) Who knows??
  • ap012199ap012199 Registered User Posts: 1,624 Senior Member
    edited August 2016
    @ithinkuracontra wow that's so cool! I feel exactly the same way. I just toured Harvard and Brown for the second time last week and Brown just feels right. Definitely going ED to Brown.
  • ithinkuracontraithinkuracontra Registered User Posts: 50 Junior Member
    Have you by chance done Experience Brown? If not, I'd definitely recommend it, although it doesn't seem like you need help making up your mind, haha. It's the program where they match you up with a student, go to lunch with them, and then go to one of their classes. I went in February, and not even the dreary weather could deter my spirits! That's when I knew 100% that Brown was the school for me. I had that "feeling." Sitting in on the class there (it was a medical anthropology class.. not even the academic area I'm interested in) really did it for me because by observing the students and the learning environment, I felt this overwhelming passion amongst everyone in the room. I just knew that I wanted to be a part of it!

    Not to be creepy or anything, but I went through some of your posts and all and we also have more similarities. I'm also at a 32 ACT with a 33.25 superscore... desperately trying to get that superscore into one solid score. I'll be retaking this September. But if that doesn't work out, I'm still kinda worried about that score not being "stellar" enough. Hopefully, other things in my application will carry me more than my score. Your freefrunning EC definitely seems unique enough!!
  • ap012199ap012199 Registered User Posts: 1,624 Senior Member
    edited August 2016
    @ithinkuracontra I'm retaking it in September too!! Really want a 34 but realistically probably a 33. But if we get rejected with 32s, it'll be because of something else in our apps. Having the average score is by no means reason for rejection. I really want to try the Experience Brown thing! I'll see if I can go back in the fall.
  • ithinkuracontraithinkuracontra Registered User Posts: 50 Junior Member
    Haha same. I'm just going to try my best, and if my best is a 32, then all I can do is move forward and work really hard on my app in every other way.

    But for now, good luck to you in September! You can do it!!!
  • eyrar99eyrar99 Registered User Posts: 491 Member
    edited August 2016
    When I visited this month, they said there was "no large advantage to ED" and that most of the ED admissions bump is from recruited athletes.

    I'm applying to Brown RD this fall! I would apply ED just to know sooner, but I need some grades from this semester on my application. I'm not worried about testing (I got a 36), but I'm nervous because I got a B- in a college class last spring and am worried it will look like I'm not ready for college academics.
  • ap012199ap012199 Registered User Posts: 1,624 Senior Member
    @eyrar99 I'm sure you'll be fine in the RD round. I just feel like applying ED without any hooks shows genuine interest in the school. Plus, I'm gearing my whole app (including my personal statement) to things unique to Brown.

    I have a 32 (33 super score) ACT. If I get deferred/rejected, will my ACT score be the reason?
  • TerpDad888TerpDad888 Registered User Posts: 61 Junior Member
    I think the higher ED admit rate is largely fueled by athletics. I don't think it lessens your chance but the much higher admit rate I believe is deceptive. Good luck either way.
  • wrenegadewrenegade Registered User Posts: 20 New Member
    On my school's naviance website, the ED acceptance rate is 38% while the RD acceptance rate is 7%.

    The average accepted GPA for ED is slightly lower than for RD. However, the average applied GPA for ED is slightly higher than for RD.

    Do what you want with the info
  • ap012199ap012199 Registered User Posts: 1,624 Senior Member
    @wrenegade that's an insane difference!! We're any of those kids recruited athletes?? Do the test scores work out the same way as the GPA does?
  • wrenegadewrenegade Registered User Posts: 20 New Member
    @ap012199 yeah! it is pretty insane! I don't really have any ways of telling if any of the kids were recruited athletes. If it helps, the lowest accepted GPA for ED is MUCH lower than that for RD so I'm sure athletics was a factor in some of the decisions.

    Also, yeah, the test scores are pretty parallel with GPA
  • NYMomof2NYMomof2 Registered User Posts: 6,014 Senior Member
    DS was accepted ED last year (just moved him into his dorm yesterday). There is information available which makes it possible to remove the effect of athletes. Brown publishes the number of ED applicants, the number accepted, and the percent of admitted students who are recruited athletes.

    I wish you all the best of luck! I can't imagine a more wonderful school than Brown.
  • ap012199ap012199 Registered User Posts: 1,624 Senior Member
    @NYMomof2 can you post a link for the stats? Thanks for the reply!
  • NYMomof2NYMomof2 Registered User Posts: 6,014 Senior Member
    I don't know how to cut and paste on my phone (cue mocking laughter from my sons), but if you google "brown university ed admission athletes" it will be the 3rd result, from the Brown Daily Herald, 12/10/15.
This discussion has been closed.