Please Help us evaluate our chances of brown, and also if we should consider ED and if you have any insight on Brown's past of twin acceptances.
White Male, from NYC, Huge NYC HS- 1000+in each class
ACT:30 E-31 M-31 R-32 S-25 8 Essay (retaking in sept)
SAT II's: USH: 790 Math IIC: 650 (will retake) Planning on taking physics SATII.
3 AP's junior year (most possible) 5 on psych and USH, 4 on English composition
GPA, don't know out of a 4.0 scale but it's 99+ (weighted) probably 97 UW
Twin Two (also a male)
ACT:33 (36 eng, 33 math) 9 essay
SAT II's: USH 800 MATH IIC 710 (will retake)
SAT I: 2020 (700 cr + 660 on writing/ math, 11 essay(hopefully Brown will neglect this score for the 33 ACT).
3 AP's (same AP's), 5 on all
Same GPA (slightly lower, but ever so slight) as twin one
Rank (both): Top 5% of a moderately competitive Public High School (school sends a few to top colleges and Ivy's every year).
Senior Courseload for both twins: 4 AP's (BC calc, Chem, Gov, lit) also other courses (senior Band), honors everything possible.
Extracurriculars (for both twins)
BBYO (Jewish youth organization), 8+ hours a week (twin one has a leadership position for two years, twin two does not)
Student Advisory Council to the Queens District Attorney (only two selected from school, out of 1,000 candidates)- 11th grade
Key Club (Twin two is secretary, but both are very active members) 10-12
Community service hours estimated around 120 hours from 10-12
Went on 7 walks for a plethora of causes (Leukemia, Aids, Breast Cancer, etc)
Saxophone, 7-12th grade (not a music major)
Both members of Arista (National Honor Society), co heads of tutoring department (10 hours/week)
Co-founded school's Law newspaper, developing a staff for my senior year
Graduating our HS with a "law" diploma for doing several law courses and completing a law program.
Both volunteered in school's book room everyday (5hrs/week)-11th grade
2nd twin- Questbridge collegeprep scholarship award winner + Edward Fein scholarship award winner, national commendation from PSAT, First place science fair- 10th grade
Presidential Award for Academic Excellence - 9th grade
Honor Roll, every semester- 9-12th grade
Merit awards in science, foreign language, English
Special recognition in chemistry (Teachers assistant credit as well)
Work Experience: Both volunteered in an inner city nursery school in a very economically disadvantaged neighborhood (Summer of 9th grade)
Counselors at another inner city day camp for economically disadvantaged youth (last summer and this summer).
Twin two looks as a stronger candidate than Twin 1, do you think they will reject twin 1 and admit twin 2/ accept both as a package? I am really interested in knowing Brown's Twin admit history. Thanks for any feedback.