I've been accepted into both Stern and the college of arts & sciences at Cornell. At Stern I'd be able to major in finance and marketing, and I've heard it's very easy to get internships, and ultimately helps a lot in landing a Wall St. job. At Cornell I got into the Dean's Scholars Program, which has some academic perks like special seminars and the chance to apply for a research grant later on.
Cornell's also got much better overall name recognition than NYU.
I hope to get an MBA after working a couple of years (probably in finance or marketing), and according to US News Cornell was ranked #1 for undergrad business schools in placement for top MBA programs (NYU was ranked 20-something).