right arrow
Examples: Monday, today, last week, Mar 26, 3/26/04

Cal Poly grads have highest salaries of all CSUs, higher than most UCs

vballmomvballmom 3085 replies50 threads Senior Member
graduates of Cal Poly San Luis Obispo earn just as much as graduates of the private Pomona College or University of Southern California -- at less than half the cost.

This is from payscale.com, comparing starting and mid-career salaries of graduates with bachelor degrees.

California State University puts price on education - San Jose Mercury News
edited May 2013
57 replies
Post edited by vballmom on
· Reply · Share
«13

Replies to: Cal Poly grads have highest salaries of all CSUs, higher than most UCs

  • ickglueickglue 282 replies1 threads Junior Member
    It is interesting (sort of weird) that UCSD earn more than UCLA.

    But it is even more interesting that Cal Poly earn more than all UCs except for Cal and UCSD.

    Great post! Thanks
    · Reply · Share
  • Socal70Socal70 306 replies20 threads Member
    nobody believes that cal poly is actually a really good school.
    · Reply · Share
  • NBrinkNBrink 205 replies3 threads Junior Member
    "nobody believes that cal poly is actually a really good school."

    Yeah... about that... who is this nobody? Most HR people I've talked to (mostly at engineering firms) have a really high opinion of Cal Poly. Sure, plenty of people from my old high school scoff at it because it's a CSU and not a UC, of course most of them didn't make it into Cal Poly, but it has a very good reputation among employers.
    · Reply · Share
  • 2Leashes2Leashes 1546 replies86 threads Senior Member
    I've been very impressed with all the positive and upbeat feedback I get about Cal Poly, in general. When I wear my sweatshirt around, there isn't a day that goes by that someone doesn't have something good to say about Cal Poly. "Oh, I'm an alum!" Or, "My kids went there and loved it!" Or, "My senior in h.s. really wants to be accepted there. We've heard it's not easy getting in." I'm amazed at how many people comment when they find out my daughter is a freshman there.
    · Reply · Share
  • Socal70Socal70 306 replies20 threads Member
    Oops. I meant back at my high school and among my asian friends.
    But among employers, of course Cal Poly is highly respected. =P
    · Reply · Share
  • ickglueickglue 282 replies1 threads Junior Member
    All of the recent positive news about Cal Poly seems to signal some kind of gradual but inexorable change in the reputation and the standing of the University. The fact that it outranked all of the UCs except UCSD (a virtual tie) and Cal is a testament to CP's improvements. Added to this, the Wall Street Journal recruiter ranking that put CP ahead of UCLA for engineering is a definitive proof of its rise.

    We all have read general blanket negative statements here on CC about CP, mainly attributing it to being a CSU and hence inherently inferior compare to any UCs.

    But it seems with the gradual increase in Cal Poly's admission selectivity, improvement in overall and department based rankings, continuing increase in graduate's earning power, and great improvements in campus facilities (among a whole host of other improvements), Cal Poly's detractors are left with less and less to assail. And Cal Poly can simply let its achievements speak for itself, and its reputation.

    In fact, I think it is a good sign that overzealous boosters of UCSD/UCSB/UCD, and UCLA were assailing Cal Poly, simply because years ago they wouldn't even care to make such comparisons because CP was so far behind.

    I am very impressed with Cal Poly because I feel like it has its "coming out" moment the last 2 years amongst the higher echelon of academia and I hope that it will continue its trajectory and work hard to achieve parity with UCSD over the coming future.
    · Reply · Share
  • dietz199dietz199 3630 replies73 threads Senior Member
    A family member who is rather high up in one of the big 8 accounting firms has one of his own kids at Cal Poly. He was quite clear that his firm recruits Cal Poly business grads because they hit the ground running.
    · Reply · Share
  • OaksMomOaksMom 602 replies13 threads Member
    Remember friends that both the Cal Polys (SLO and Pomona) adhere to a "learn by doing" philosophy. Thus the students there are getting practical knowledge and experience and not just theoretical knowledge. Big selling point to many employers I would think.
    · Reply · Share
  • momofmvmomofmv 568 replies27 threads Member
    All great reasons for going to Cal Poly! A great education for the cost and a good chance of getting a job when they graduate. Sounds good!
    · Reply · Share
  • CSUChopefulCSUChopeful 88 replies5 threads Junior Member
    Cal States are underrated.
    · Reply · Share
  • bjornredtailbjornredtail 140 replies2 threads Junior Member
    Well, I'm not convinced that number is that meaningful. Cal Poly's graduates are disproportionately in engineering and other fields that are highly paid by industry. Cal Poly graduates disproportionately go into industry right after graduating. Both of these factors will increase the reported salaries of Poly's graduates, regardless of any benefit that the graduates may or may not have received.

    This may not be a good thing. The needs of industry come before the best interests of the student. Parts of the curriculum are driven by the demands of industry for disposable workers. If you take a database class, it's going to be in Oracle. If you take a networks class, it's going to use CISCO hardware. And, yes, I do think that industry wants disposable workers. Why else is age discrimination so rampant in engineering and software development?

    You are not going to find much help from the university on going to grad school either. I'm starting to think that's intentional, to game numbers like this. You aren't allowed to switch your major, and all advice you do get comes back to this downright poisonous idea that you should get a degree so you can get a job. If that's the only reason you are getting a degree, I think you would be much better off by investing your savings and getting an apprenticeship in the skilled trades.

    I want to major in something I'm interested in. Something I enjoy doing and studying. Something that will make a real difference in the world. Instead, I'm stuck where I am, having already sunk 5 years of my life and a decant sum of money at this place. So, yes, I think Cal Poly is overrated. I think Cal Poly is a terrible university for a lot of people. It has nothing to do with some abstract notion of academic reputation or university ratings. i just do not like the educational experience I've had. Isn't what it's all about?
    · Reply · Share
  • ickglueickglue 282 replies1 threads Junior Member
    I can comprehend your dislike for your college experience. It is an experience that is very personal to you, and it is sad to hear that you have had such terrible experience for what should have been one of the most exciting and best part of one's life.

    You sounded like you were trapped in a major you don't like and an university that you felt alienated from. But in defense of Cal Poly and any other universities, you have a choice all along as to where to go and what major to pursue. You had the choice of major (barring your family forcing you to major in something you hate), and university. So I am curious why you just didn't take action and change your college experience for the better by transferring or changing major entirely?

    Not liking your educational experience is completely personal and valid opinion, but shifting the blame entirely onto the university (any universities) is just externalizing your problems onto someone else's shoulders.

    As for creating "disposable workers", I opine your thinking is flawed. According to your version of a Cal Poly graduate, they are automaton slaved to certain industry based technology standards and (by your inference) once that standards are obsolete, these Cal Poly trained drones are disposed. I agree that Cal Poly's engineering education does provide a very practical approach to a highly technical discipline, this approach does ensure the creation of a new generation of solid engineering professionals that can work in many corporate capacities right after graduation.

    But what is central, and most invaluable part, of this engineering education (I think this is true for most solid engineering schools) is that it teaches a highly discipline way of logical thinking and the nurturing of intellectual horsepower that can be leveraged throughout one's life and career. It is this discipline logical intellectual thought process that enables a Cal Poly, and other universities', engineering graduate to innovate, learn, master complex new skills and knowledge throughout one's career. Just because an engineering student is trained upon Cisco's or Oracle's standards in Cal Poly does it mean he/she can't acquire knowledge based on a new standard?

    In fact, I argue this previous exposure to a dominant industry standard would facilitate and speed up, NOT detract, the learning of a new set of highly complex technical knowledge. Your assertion that CP's graduates are "disposable" is based on the assumption of a static, corporate drone that is incapable or failed to learn/acquire/invent (or simply lack the desire to) new skills and knowledge throughout one's career. I truly feel sorry for you if that is how you see yourself and see others in Cal Poly Engineering.

    Also, there is nothing wrong with university students aspiring to get an university education so they can secure a decent high paying job. MOST university students on this planet share in that desire. Even my classmates at my Ivy league Alma Mater were gunning to land a great job in Wall street. There is nothing toxic about that. Of course, some graduates have a noble or altruistic intent to serve humanity or nature, we should celebrate that! But concurrently, graduates having a more modest ambition of having secure and productive professional lives are just as valid and deserve our respect.

    As for your assertion that money and time is better invested in an apprenticeship, I would like to hear what kind of skilled trade or apprenticeship in the US will teach you how to design a 64 bit microprocessor or hybrid electric power system or low orbital flight body?

    As for preparing Cal Poly student for graduate studies, I am not sure what kind of preparation you would expect from CP? The best preparation for any graduate school is maximizing every single learning opportunity while in undergraduate, maintaining a high GPA, getting involved with extra curricular activities, build solid relationships with the faculty, and finally, developing and nurturing your personal intellectual PASSION. Speaking only personally, that approach worked for me quite nicely during my years at Cal Poly, and that's how I got into Harvard for my graduate studies.

    As for the salary survey, CP is ranked third (behind only Cal and UVA) in earnings in the US for public universities. You can't argue that is simple because Cal Poly is a large engineering school with graduates heading into the workforce shortly after graduation. There are plenty of that type of technical universities throughout the US (e.g. Texas, Georgia, Virginia), and they are NOT all ranked third in the US.

    I would also opine that for MOST students (including me), the Cal Poly educational experience was a grand experience in so many fronts. In so many countless ways, intellectually, socially, and professionally, my Cal Poly peers and I have benefited and grew as the result of our collective college experience. And it was definitely one of the BEST time of my life.
    · Reply · Share
  • vballmomvballmom 3085 replies50 threads Senior Member
    Bjornredtail I'm sorry your experience at Cal Poly wasn't what you'd hoped.

    Nice post, ickglue.
    · Reply · Share
  • ickglueickglue 282 replies1 threads Junior Member
    Thank you. I felt the need to speak up for Cal Poly.
    · Reply · Share
  • bjornredtailbjornredtail 140 replies2 threads Junior Member
    Re, choice of major:
    College of Engineering Advising Center - Changing Majors

    Read that policy. It isn't as bad as it was in the past, but the effect still sucks. The net result is that I am not allowed to change majors. Even if I had tried two years ago, I wouldn't be allowed to change majors. My major was my choice when I came in, but it isn't now. So, I'm stuck. Maybe I can apply to grad school in the area I really wanted to study, but that will cost thousands and take 5 more years. All due to an advising center that would not help me in the slightest and policies designed to make it nearly impossible to change majors.

    Why didn't I transfer? Good question. Perhaps my parents and certain future employees are so swept up in these useless measures of academic prestige that they would be disappointed in a decision like that. Perhaps it's the amount of sunk costs, the thousands of dollars and hundreds of hours I've put into this degree. Perhaps it's the expensive 1 year lease I have to sign at an off campus housing complex. Or, perhaps I wouldn't have the faintest idea where I should go. Sometimes it's better to face the devil you know than face the unknown.

    Re, getting a degree to get a job and the skilled trades:
    If you are designing a 64 bit processor or a hybrid driveline or a low orbital flightbody, you are in it for more than just the money. I contend that you would have never made it that far if you were. I know I am...

    I would say that there is a major problem with getting a degree to get a job. We are inflating the requirements for jobs. Jobs that have no reason to require a college degree now require a college degree. This does nothing but divert value to the education sector.

    Re, thinking like an engineer:
    I suspect I could have had this same experience at hundreds of universities, some of which would have allowed me to explore other engineering fields or even change major. It might have cost far less too. You get this experience in spite of industry's involvement and the whole "learn by doing" philosophy as it is implemented here, not because of it.


    I can't really peg my dislike of Cal Poly on any single thing. I'm just tired of their parental attitude. I'm tired of their broken idea of 'due proscess'. I'm tired of the People's Republic of SLO and being treated as a second class citizen on the behest of the university. I'm tired of paying $600/month for a rat-hole apartment (which is considered a hell of a deal in SLO). I'm tired having to hunt down classes. I'm tired of being 3rd on the waitlist when the class only takes two students. I'm tired of seeing the waste and mismanagement at the top. I'm tired of special deals, copper counter-tops and do-nothing consultants. I'm tired of the corrupt and secretive Cal Poly Corporation. I'm tired of policies that require my club to pay to use their own name. I'm tired of departments that take 15% of all donations to campus organizations just for being there. I'm tired of lavish parties during a time of budget cuts. I'm tired of the ASI simply being lap dogs and refusing to take on the university when things go wrong. I'm tired of the focus on PR, on style over substance. I'm tired of the US News and World reports giving such rave reviews of the place based on what can only be described as academic brownoseing. I'm tired policies that make it nearly impossible to change major, policies that punish those who try to follow the rules. If you have seen the Cal Poly that I have seen, I think you would hate it as well.
    · Reply · Share
  • HPuck35HPuck35 2013 replies15 threads Senior Member
    bjornredtail,

    I'm sorry that your life has been so miserable and out of your control. Maybe it would be better if you just took control of it. Many people do change majors at Cal Poly. It does take some work, but so does most everything else in life.

    If you think the politics are bad at Cal Poly, just wait until you get into industry.

    I am sorry that I am coming down on you so hard but with the attitude you've shown in your posts, life after Cal Poly is going to be rough for you.
    · Reply · Share
  • CalPolyEngineerCalPolyEngineer 163 replies19 threads Junior Member
    Standing ovation to bjornredtail. Finally someone has the "cojones" to talk about the corporation known as Cal Poly(TM) and their anti-intellectual and anti-academic stances on higher education all in the name of the Orfaleas' and Spanos' (guys who didn't even attend that university).
    · Reply · Share
  • ickglueickglue 282 replies1 threads Junior Member
    bjornredtail,

    Although I don't see Cal Poly the same way as you do, you have my sympathy for the distress you are experiencing.

    I hope you will be able to find a way out in the near future. I always believe all of us have a freedom of choice and action in our lives (even in our darkest hours), and I hope you will cease the opportunity to create a better and happier life for yourself.

    And don't pay attention to other's diatribe. Your issues with Cal Poly Corporation, while possibly upsetting and painful, shouldn't really be your first priority.

    @the CPPomona student
    You go to CP Pomona and seems to be morbidly obsessed with Cal Poly's campus issues. Why?
    · Reply · Share
  • ickglueickglue 282 replies1 threads Junior Member
    bjornredtail,

    I neglected to mention, I wholeheartedly agree with HPUCK35. Whatever political BS/corruption/wastage you might experience at Cal Poly, it is going to look benign and trivial in comparison to the corporate world.

    While advising some of US' Fortune 50 corporations, I have seen some breathtaking level of corruption, incompetence, and corporate misdeeds that you can't begin to imagine. So if you want to be cynical, disgusted, and apathetic, please wait until after graduation.

    And just so you know Cal Poly engineering graduates are not all drones, shortly after my graduation, I did get to design, from scratch, a 32-bit compressed video router/microprocessor that powers DirectTV's entire video traffic backbone.
    · Reply · Share
  • bjornredtailbjornredtail 140 replies2 threads Junior Member
    Does take some work? I'm a 5th year senior with a ton of useless extra units. I will exceed the unit caps if I were to switch to anything else in the College of Engineering. And it will delay graduation by some time (which, to be fair, is to be expected), which means that cannot be allowed (it might hurt the 6 year graduation rate). So... No. They will not let me. My only hope is to get another degree (since, as you folks so artfully pointed out, engineering requires some formal education) somewhere else. That's 5 more years in school. Tell me, where in the hell am I going to get the money for that? Am I supposed to put my life on hold for another 5 years? All because someone thought it would be a great idea to reduce the time to graduation by eliminating our choice in the matter.

    You are not allowed to switch majors unless you can justify it somehow to some department head who has every reason to say no. That is a major educational failure. How can Cal Poly's defenders see this any other way? Part of the reason for all those GE and support classes we take is to see if we have talents in areas outside our major. The College of Engineering's current policy makes it impossible to follow any of those intrests. So long as I get credit for my preforming ensembles, I can't even take a single 4-unit class that isn't towards my degree. Not to mention that none of the engineering programs offer a minor (except Computer Science). Doesn't that completely defeat the point of undergraduate education? It's like saying "Be well rounded, but only as well rounded as we say".

    It's not just an abstract rant against the corrupt nature of the politics of SLO and Cal Poly. Each part of my rant is something I've experienced personally. I've seen Warren Baker's copper counter-tops. I have run useless errands for the folks in the Admin building (of course, I got paid for that... I acctually miss that job). I have had Corporation attempt to charge my club to use our own name. I've been scared away from changing major or even taking classes outside my major. I've been number 3 on a waitlist of class that has only taken 2 people. I've experienced Cal Poly's version of "due process", and I've seen friends fall victim to it as well. As I said before, if you experienced what I experienced, you would hate Cal Poly.

    So, it gets worse in industry? How is that relevant? Because things are worse in industry, I shouldn't care? Perhaps I should ask, why don't you care? Did your engineering degree include a professional ethics class? Man, they need to start making the CPEs take 300.
    · Reply · Share
This discussion has been closed.

Recent Activity