Welcome to College Confidential!

The leading college-bound community on the web

Sign Up For Free

Join for FREE, and start talking with other members, weighing in on community discussions, and more.

Also, by registering and logging in you'll see fewer ads and pesky welcome messages (like this one!)

As a CC member, you can:

  • Reply to threads, and start your own.
  • Post reviews of your campus visits.
  • Find hundreds of pages of informative articles.
  • Search from over 3 million scholarships.
Introducing a New Expert Content Section: Careers!

Freshman Art Major: Macbook or Imac?

EMmullyEMmully Registered User Posts: 1 New Member
edited March 2013 in College Computers
Next year I will be a freshman art student, and after foundation year I plan on either majoring in illustration or animation. However, for the start of next year, I'm planning on getting a new computer, but I haven't been able to figure out what would be a better choice. I have emailed the school, and they say that a laptop is not necessary freshman year due to the quality of their computer labs.

I do own a (very) basic HP laptop right now that would do well for email/general web browsing, but I plan on doing digital art. I love the portability of the laptop, but the imac has much better specs than the macbook pro.

Would you recommend that I get the imac and keep my current laptop, or get a macbook pro?

Thank you!
Post edited by EMmully on

Replies to: Freshman Art Major: Macbook or Imac?

  • ChronologyChronology Registered User Posts: 62 Junior Member
    Animation software (Autodesk) runs better on PC.
  • BlowOffValveBlowOffValve Registered User Posts: 23 New Member
    If you love the portability of the Macbook Pro, you should go with it instead of the iMac. It's easier to bring along when you're on break. That being said, the iMac could provide you with a higher resolution (depending on which MBP and iMac; the rMBP 15" has a resolution of 2880x1800 whereas the 27" iMac has a resolution of 2560x1440.) They both have IPS panels so that's a big plus for color accuracy. However, it sounds like you might be doing a lot of the work in the lab anyways so I'd lean towards a MBP, depending on the model that is.

    (Chronology is also heavily biased in his responses and has a prejudice against Apple computers.)
  • ChronologyChronology Registered User Posts: 62 Junior Member
    Yes, attack me, not the argument.
  • BlowOffValveBlowOffValve Registered User Posts: 23 New Member
    There was no argument. There was a statement that said that animation software runs better on PC. It wasn't relevant to the OP's question and didn't answer the question on hand. Besides, Macs are PCs. What is there to argue?

    I mean, if someone created a thread asking whether they should get a British Shorthair or Munchkin cat; what's the point of just saying that Dogs are better than cats?
  • ChronologyChronology Registered User Posts: 62 Junior Member
    Considering that MOST Mac users are ignorant consumers, I just gave some information related to the topic that would help choose the best possible computer for the given task. Also, I know much more about Macs(and animation software) than most(if not all) other users on this forum because I actually took the time to reverse engineer its unique features (aside from UNIX) for my operating systems class in college.

    If it wasn't clear already, By PC I meant Windows based, and by Mac I meant OSX based. Basically any software that exists on both operating systems is almost always better optimized on the PC. If you plan on doing work that is resource heavy, the PC is the better choice. Therefore, for animation I would recommend getting an iMac with windows installed(Or PC hardware equivalent).
  • BlowOffValveBlowOffValve Registered User Posts: 23 New Member
    I'll admit that I don't know much about computer animation since I've never cared much for it, but I am familiar with Autodesk products such as AutoCAD. I do like CAD on Windows better due to the interface and the fact that it has less minor glitches, mainly because the Mac version is still young. So there is that. To say that most Mac users are ignorant consumers is what I'm talking about when I point out your bias. You're on a site where many people are not knowledgeable on computers in general which may be why you have that view towards Mac consumers or you find a lot of teenagers who get 13" MBPs, but if you go on a different site actually dedicated to technology, you will find people who are knowledgable that may prefer Mac and/or UNIX. Also work that is "resource heavy" is done in UNIX, not Windows. You won't many servers that run on Windows or even personal "supercomputers" that run Windows. (quotes around supercomputers)
    Finally, you can't say that Apple makes bad products either. You may not like Apple the corporation or Apple's pricing, which is understandable, but the products themselves aren't bad.



    You know, that last sentence of yours, "Therefore, for animation I would recommend getting an iMac with Windows installed(Or PC hardware equivalent)." is one that I actually agree with.
  • oseymouroseymour Registered User Posts: 3 New Member
    The new macbook pros with Retina display are nice and you have the ability to be mobile and can work/study anywhere.

    I recommend getting at least the 15 inch.

    Apple - MacBook Pro
  • ALFALF Registered User Posts: 1,171 Senior Member
    I should think that you would want a portable computer so that you can work wherever you want. I don't know much about art, but I do know about CAD and 2D/3D Engineering design applications. You will probably want the biggest screen you can get. Perhaps the best compromise is a MacBook Pro and a large monitor that you can plug into when you are in your residence. The nice thing about that setup is that you will then have two monitors, one for your main window, and the other for palettes and tool windows.
This discussion has been closed.