Join for FREE,
and start talking with other members, weighing in on community discussions,
Also, by registering and logging in you'll see fewer ads and pesky
welcome messages (like this one!)
Why the binary distinction? Clearly, there exists a hierarchy between targets and non-targets. But among the targets, individual ability trumps school affiliation.
School A has undergrad population of 100 and grad population of 10. Assume for the sake of simplicity that under and phd last one year.
All undergrads at school A decide to go to grad school, so 0% are "pre-professional." But, because the grad school has a max population of 10, we get 10/100*1000=100 = Score A. The other students have to go to another school for grad school.
Now let's look at school B. It looks exactly the same as School A (# under at A= # under at B and # phd at A=# phd at B) with the excpetion that people at B hate phd and just want to work/go to law/medicine/etc.
Because of this, 0% of undergrads at B are going to get a PHD and 100% are "pre-professional" Size of Phd program stays the same and just recruits from other undergrad colleges for Phd class. Score B = 10/100*1000=100= Score of A.
So two scenarios:
School A in which 100% of undergrads are "pre-professional" and school A gets score of 100.
School B in which 0 % of undergrads are "pre-professional" and school B gets score of 100.
Your score on this list tells us little to nothing about the percentage of undergrads at the school that are "pre-professional". What affects the scores are the sizes of the under and grad programs.
columbia probably has more folks than other ivies that enter into education, non-profit and in general social justice work - i will offer anecdotally.
I am fairly certain that the study tracks whether or not undergraduate alumni/ae receive PhDs, not where they received them. But if you want to look at the (NSF) list which shows the "percentage of undergrads [that] go on to [successfully] pursue PHDs," here you go:
nsf.gov - SRS Baccalaureate Origins of S&E Doctorate Recipients - US National Science Foundation (NSF)