Welcome to College Confidential!

The leading college-bound community on the web

Sign Up For Free

Join for FREE, and start talking with other members, weighing in on community discussions, and more.

Also, by registering and logging in you'll see fewer ads and pesky welcome messages (like this one!)

As a CC member, you can:

  • Reply to threads, and start your own.
  • Post reviews of your campus visits.
  • Find hundreds of pages of informative articles.
  • Search from over 3 million scholarships.
The Forums will be unavailable Tuesday, June 25 starting at 9 am ET as we prepare for a major design update!

Odds at Goldman--very bad

1356

Replies to: Odds at Goldman--very bad

  • DawgieDawgie Registered User Posts: 1,576 Senior Member
    VectorWega whats your job experience?
  • VectorWegaVectorWega Registered User Posts: 1,872 Senior Member
    Well, I'm not looking to go Ibanking so it's quite irrelevant. I've made a lot of money in real estate and that's what I'll stick to when I decide to come out of retirement.
  • DawgieDawgie Registered User Posts: 1,576 Senior Member
    Top 20 MBA itself, is roughly 650-700+ GMAT, respectable undergrad GPA, and solid work experience (4 years on average I believe). Now after you've achieved that, 10% of those get into IBanking?
  • DawgieDawgie Registered User Posts: 1,576 Senior Member
    Most of you that are interested in Investment Banking will not make it so just give up and stop discussing it. More importantly, spend that time that you have used dreaming about banking, into a career that you will actually enjoy and excel at.
  • DawgieDawgie Registered User Posts: 1,576 Senior Member
    The point of me asking your work experience was because if you think Investment Banking isn't difficult to get into from your point of view, you must have some amazing credentials. You must have gotten jobs that were signficantly harder to get than investment banking (which hardly exist, consulting?)to claim that it is "not difficult" correct?
  • VectorWegaVectorWega Registered User Posts: 1,872 Senior Member
    Now after you've achieved that, 10% of those get into IBanking?

    At this school, 10% go into IB, but only 40% go into finance at all. So a 25% rate is probably more accurate but you have to consider that many of those in finance probably don't want to go IB simply due to the long hours etc.

    Talking to students from another school (actually, not even a top 50 MBA program) they told me that many of their fellow students wanted to go IB when they started their MBA but by the time they've really learned more about IB most change their mind (BTW, that school also sends people into IB despite not being a top 50 program).

    I'm sure it is quite difficult to get into IB from undergrad. However, if you really desire to be IB then you can always fall back on an MBA and have what appears to be a very good chance at going IB. (especially if u come from a finance background which should give you an edge once in business school).
  • VectorWegaVectorWega Registered User Posts: 1,872 Senior Member
    BTW, this thread is not simply about IB'ing. It's about any position that Goldman Sachs has. This would include IT, analyst, and advisor roles (and probably many other roles also). They also probably receive a ton of resumes from people that are not good fits at all.
  • jnpnjnpn Registered User Posts: 787 Member
    Dawgie-- 40% from Ross (almost half of all Ross students don't seek jobs in finance). This is for undergrad. There are some schools that have an even easier time breaking in to the industry.
  • DawgieDawgie Registered User Posts: 1,576 Senior Member
    Yea I'll agree a few schools give you a much better chance, but realistically I'm trying to do most of these kids a favor.
  • redhare317redhare317 Registered User Posts: 1,449 Senior Member
    Ross is a target, but that 40% might be misleading.

    First of all, it's according to how many people responded to the career survey, so everything is self-reported material. Of course we can assume that a good number out of the 350 graduates did the survey, and most probably answered as accurately as possible. But still, the 40% is not 40% of students but rather 40% of respondents.

    Second of all (and more importantly), many jobs can be classified as "investment banking" that actually aren't traditionally IB. And it can be anywhere in the world. Just look through the Ross job database (search by "finance-investment banking") or postings on Vault or **** for "investment banking" and you'll know what I mean. You'll see a list of random firms/positions. The real % we need to know is % going into a BB (or top boutique) in NYC as an IB analyst, eliminating firms and positions (and probably even locations) that don't traditionally count.

    I know a Ross student who graduated in 2004. He went to GS. He said only one other person that year became an analyst in IB in NYC. The rest were non-IB positions and/or not in NYC. I'll try to get more details on that, but that's what he said.
  • jnpnjnpn Registered User Posts: 787 Member
    First of all, it's according to how many people responded to the career survey, so everything is self-reported material. Of course we can assume that a good number out of the 350 graduates did the survey, and most probably answered as accurately as possible. But still, the 40% is not 40% of students but rather 40% of respondents.

    This is true. Most grads will respond to the survey (heard it was ~90%), but you have to take the number with a grain of salt.
    The real % we need to know is % going into a BB (or top boutique) in NYC as an IB analyst

    I was talking about investment banking as a whole in response to Dawgie's statement about investment banking job prospects in general. The answer to this would be useful, but doesn't really pertain to what I was talking about. BB analysts in the IBD division of the NYC offices are not the only investment bankers.
    I know a Ross student who graduated in 2004. He went to GS. He said only one other person that year became an analyst in IB in NYC. The rest were non-IB positions and/or not in NYC. I'll try to get more details on that, but that's what he said.

    Considering goldman only took four grads in 2004, that is very possible. The others were probably in S&T and/or the Chicago office (god forbid!).
  • UntiltedUntilted Registered User Posts: 1,980 Senior Member
    mckinsey has internships. recruited a couple of kids in my school last year.
  • DawgieDawgie Registered User Posts: 1,576 Senior Member
    McKinsey interships are located inside your school? Cool!
  • redhare317redhare317 Registered User Posts: 1,449 Senior Member
    Ok, the 4 going to GS clears up a lot. I was wondering about that myself. Then it makes sense in that context.

    You mention "investment banking as a whole" and that's okay, but when most people say they want investment banking, they're not talking about being an IB analyst at W.Y Campbell & Co. in Detroit or Stout Rissius Ross in Farmington Hills or National City bank, etc. The 40% includes ALL of those types of firms, which is misleading. It doesn't mean 2 out of 5 people will make it big in IB (i.e. BB firm or top boutique) like the statistic makes you want to think. Talk to the juniors and seniors. They'll tell you all about the interviews they couldn't get and the interviews they got but couldn't "pass," for lack of a better word. IB is a tough field, and you're in for some competition for the TOP IB jobs. That's all I was saying.
  • DawgieDawgie Registered User Posts: 1,576 Senior Member
    I should clarify, I am talking about getting into BB's.
This discussion has been closed.