Welcome to College Confidential!

The leading college-bound community on the web

Sign Up For Free

Join for FREE, and start talking with other members, weighing in on community discussions, and more.

Also, by registering and logging in you'll see fewer ads and pesky welcome messages (like this one!)

As a CC member, you can:

  • Reply to threads, and start your own.
  • Post reviews of your campus visits.
  • Find hundreds of pages of informative articles.
  • Search from over 3 million scholarships.
Please take a moment to read our updated TOS, Privacy Policy, and Forum Rules.

Should Study Hall/Free Period be counted toward GPA?

Aj39vn23cf2Aj39vn23cf2 Registered User Posts: 398 Junior Member
edited May 2011 in High School Life
This is, or hopefully will be, a discussion thread.

I'm of the opinion that it should negatively affect a students GPA. The point of a weighted GPA is to make sure that students are rewarded by taking the hardest classes possible. The current Val at my school has 4 AP classes and 3 study halls - but only the AP classes count toward his GPA.

I get angry at that - if you want to be Val, you should have to work for your GPA!

Anyway. Maybe I'm being to militant. I'm still a little miffed this is the strategy for most kids at my school. A penny for your thoughts?
Post edited by Aj39vn23cf2 on

Replies to: Should Study Hall/Free Period be counted toward GPA?

  • madogmgdmadogmgd - Posts: 1,068 Senior Member
    Valedictorian is such a joke now and days.
    Anybody can cheat to get it.

    As long as your in the top 5% who cares anyway.
  • IlyanaIlyana Registered User Posts: 472 Junior Member
    Definitely not. Think about the kids that can't do much work at home for some reason (home problems, lack of stability, library shut down) and need a free period to get their work done. Why punish them?

    I'm sorry that your valedictorian cheated to get their #1 spot. Life will go on, especially if you have a high class rank.
  • FrancaisalamattFrancaisalamatt Registered User Posts: 1,839 Senior Member
    So because of this one extreme example that ONLY affects you, we should penalize everyone who has a study hall? Why should anything have a negative effect on your GPA? Makes no sense.
  • BillyMcBillyMc . Posts: 7,753 Senior Member
    How do you grade a free period?
  • emeraldEviemeraldEvi Registered User Posts: 186 Junior Member
    I know where you're coming from-- kids with 5 APs and 3 study halls can have higher GPAs than kids with 6 APs and two elective courses, and it's not fair, but hopefully colleges recognize that.
  • Aj39vn23cf2Aj39vn23cf2 Registered User Posts: 398 Junior Member
    I'm not being negatively affected by this. If I am not able to become Valedictorian, it will be because I earned a final grade of a "B" in English One my Frosh year. There are other reasons, of course (it's never just one reason), but I won't bore anyone with them. I am not personally hurt by people who take advantage of study hall. That is not the reason why I started this thread.

    I just find it...detestable? that people can and will cheat to improve their class rank. I agree with what IIyana said about some students having special circumstances that would necessitate school time to finish work.

    On the other hand, emeraldEvi pointed out what I'm annoyed by. There are people who need it and people who "abuse" it. My question is: if you could change the current system, would you?
  • notanengineernotanengineer Registered User Posts: 1,125 Senior Member
    If there are any people out there who need a study hall to do all of their homework in one day, then it should be mandated for everyone, or the people who need it should take it at their own expense. Otherwise there is a bias against people who are taking actual classes when they have the chance.

    People who take 4 APs and 3 study halls are stealing others' class rank in order to achieve a meaningless title. They'll still get rejected from competitive colleges because they have weak schedules (hopefully), so they're just screwing their classmates over.
  • SharonSUNYSharonSUNY Registered User Posts: 444 Member
    How would it be graded?
  • IlyanaIlyana Registered User Posts: 472 Junior Member
    Well just know that colleges will probably find it odd that they've only taken four classes when they could've taken seven.
  • AerobugAerobug Registered User Posts: 773 Member
    No, it shouldn't count negatively toward your grade because some people actually NEED them.

    I suffer from ADD and need my study hall in order to focus on my work without any nearby distractions. My study hall has saved my life in the past 2 years, though I won't have it junior/senior year.
    I think 3 study halls is a little much, though I'm sure colleges will make that decision, not you. So relax and don't worry about other people's courseloads. The school Val isn't going to influence your admission into college, nor are they choosing where you go.
  • artickoalabearartickoalabear Registered User Posts: 132 Junior Member
    I take one study hall, because I just get blatantly distracted! I mean, I am much more motivated at school because hey, what else is there to do?

    I don't see how someone gets a higher GPA and takes more study halls but life goes on as someone else said.
  • AUGirlAUGirl Registered User Posts: 2,890 Senior Member
    At my school, you're required to maintain a minimum of five academic courses a year. So technically, you should only have a maximum of two study halls per day... but due to scheduling conflicts, there are some kids in my grade this year with three study halls. They're nowhere near the top of the class though.

    I've always been the kid to overload on classes, but this year I made sure that as a senior, I had two study halls. I feel like I deserve it though. In 10th grade, I took nine classes and in 11th grade, I took eight. Most kids only took five or six. This year I'm taking five, but I still have four APs and that's considered a high course load.
This discussion has been closed.