Welcome to College Confidential!

The leading college-bound community on the web

Sign Up For Free

Join for FREE, and start talking with other members, weighing in on community discussions, and more.

Also, by registering and logging in you'll see fewer ads and pesky welcome messages (like this one!)

As a CC member, you can:

  • Reply to threads, and start your own.
  • Post reviews of your campus visits.
  • Find hundreds of pages of informative articles.
  • Search from over 3 million scholarships.
Please take a moment to read our updated TOS, Privacy Policy, and Forum Rules.

Coldest rejection letters/Kindest letters

SuNaSuNa Registered User Posts: 923 Member
edited March 2010 in Parents Forum
It might be fun to take a look at some rejection letter "winners." Coldest, for example, and then kindest. So -- lay them down here.

I hear Babson had a real coldie.
Post edited by SuNa on

Replies to: Coldest rejection letters/Kindest letters

  • kevster1001kevster1001 Registered User Posts: 2,559 Senior Member
    there's a thread around CC that's about this.
    Just a quick scoop, based on an article that mentioned about CC and CCers, Stanford had the coldest, Rutgers had the best (dont know about kindness) but acceptances came in in a very expensive-looking jet black folder.
  • heartcrossheartcross Registered User Posts: 637 Member
    Well, the military academies probably have the nicest acceptance notifications--personal phone calls from your Congressman! And they send cool folders to boot (with voluminous instructions on all sorts of medical things and even what boots to buy for AFA). The Congressman's office often sends a nice press release to your local paper. Can't get much nicer than that!
  • emswimemswim Registered User Posts: 474 Member
    Princeton's has two sheets of paper in it, so when you open it you think you've at least been waitlisted.
  • xgyrosxxgyrosx Registered User Posts: 106 Junior Member
    H has the longest--so maybe the kindest--rejection letter. Others have like three to five sentences.
  • IzzyJIzzyJ Registered User Posts: 3,271 Senior Member
    I read Duke's rejection letter. It's utterly sweet.
  • sbroy81188sbroy81188 Registered User Posts: 60 Junior Member
    Not to give my intellegence level away, but I was kind of confused by the wait list letter I received from Harvard.... I thought they were telling me that they couldn't make a decision due to an incomplete application!!! I hear you laughing over there.
  • ayzdadayzdad Registered User Posts: 80 Junior Member
    i see this thread is 4 years old. that's perfect. my son got a waitlist letter in 2006 from Holy Cross (Worcester, Ma) and it was pretty cold. The tone sounded like 'our standards are quite high, so surely my dear fellow you can understand we can't admit just anybody'. Which sort of figures, because they intimate that the more you beg and grovel, the more likely you'll be admitted. The way they put it is that they 'love communication'. My daughter was going to apply to HC n/w/s the attitude but she got into Notre Dame early action, so that was that.
  • rocket6louiserocket6louise Registered User Posts: 3,391 Senior Member
    the kindest acceptance was from Union

    "The answer is yes, a resounding yes"
  • cnp55cnp55 Registered User Posts: 3,707 Senior Member
    Bucknell's rejection had a nice message in the third paragraph:
    I encourage you to remain confident as you continue your college search. Many colleges and universities are eager to enroll students who are passionate about academics and campus life. Your interest in Bucknell is a sign that you have this passion. Rest assured that you will find the right school for you.

    A little bit of blowing their own horn and a little bit of letting them down easy ... but it's better than a certain university in Washington DC who coldly said denied with a terse few words that paraphrase as no room for the likes of you.
  • NHmom10NHmom10 Registered User Posts: 62 Junior Member
    rocket6 - those folks at Union do it nicely for waitlist, also...
    This process can be a difficult one and the depth of the applicant pool forces us to say "maybe" instead of "yes" to a number of appealing candidates like you.

    Sounds so much better than "take a number and we'll get back to you" LOL!
  • Lafalum84Lafalum84 Registered User Posts: 7,532 Senior Member
    Not a college rejection, but my son emailed the woman who had interviewed him for a summer internship he was really excited about, asking when he could expect to hear back from regarding the internship. He received an email back with the subject line:
    Reject email not in hire

    Cryptic and harsh at the same time.
  • blackeyedsusanblackeyedsusan Registered User Posts: 2,494 Senior Member
    ^^^ Oooh, that's cold!
  • psych_psych_ Registered User Posts: 1,568 Senior Member
    "The answer is yes, a resounding yes"

    That is nice! :)
  • greenvisongreenvison Registered User Posts: 491 Member
    Lat year I was emailed a rejection from an internship, it went something like this ->

    Dear "Applicant",
    blah blah blah( like two lines in total!)


    wow, that really P***** me off. I had two interviews with them, and they still couldn't personalize the damn email.
  • samedifferencesamedifference Registered User Posts: 316 Member
    UCLA's rejection was terrible. In then end it had a line about what to do if you want to transfer. I liked Berkeley's rejection, though. It was short but nice.
This discussion has been closed.