2011 PA Scores

xiggi
Fri, 20 Aug 2010 17:47:04 +0000

Are you going to make an effort to address some of the examples in Post #52?



Not really, and for a number of reasons.


I do not see the relevance to the Peer Assessment’s instructions
I do not know those programs
I DO know why you ask the question.


Considering the three points listed above, I find it easier to pass. Except, for repeating that evaluating the graduate programs should be not be relevant to the responders, and if they, just as I did admit, do NOT know enough to evaluate the undergraduate programs, they SHOULD answer I DO NOT KNOW. They should not speculate or respond to a questions that is NOT posed.

As far as your position, I speculate that you will say that the departments are so intertwined that it is impossible to evaluate them individually. However, again, that goes back to my point that the CURRENT Peer Assessment is an incredibly poorly executed and futile exercise.