Are music competitions necessary?

ProMusician
Wed, 24 Jul 2013 09:19:22 +0000

“Competitions are for horses, not artists.”–Bela Bartok

Don’t tell Mr. Bartok that I only partially agree with this…! Rather than repeat what many of the posters have already said about competitions–and I agree that much can be gained from entering them, especially if there is a financial incentive–I’d like to also assert that the college audition will be the most important factor. As violindad stated, there are so many prospective students, it’s difficult to keep track of that type of information, and I honestly don’t know many professors who put a lot of stock into them anyhow. The audition performance will tell them what they need to know.

In addition, many view competitions as a very narrow way of assessing talent because frequently, winners are chosen for their flashy display of technique and stage presence, rather than presenting true musicianship. Technical mastery is a means to an end…a tool for musical expression, not the ultimate goal. Some of these competition winners have perfected the art of winning, and ultimately do not possess the important characteristics necessary for a career.

Feedback also must be weighed carefully–both positive and negative–unless consistently mentioned in the comments sheets. For example, if “beautiful tone” appears time after time, it’s probably safe to assume that the performer has a gorgeous sound. If “work on intonation” is a constant theme, it’s probably safe to assume that the performer should work on their pitch. It’s important to take into consideration the feedback that applies (and asking your private instructor for perspective on this) and forget about what doesn’t. Easy to say, sometimes difficult to do.

It’s interesting that your son’s private teacher does not hold recitals, but nothing is preventing you from presenting your own private concert. Churches, schools are good options, and so is your house, or the home of a friend. I highly recommend it as it’s great preparation for those upcoming college auditions. Best of luck to you and your son!