are Religious people mentally Ill?

BigG
Sat, 03 Jan 2009 00:33:11 +0000

The original question is an example of circular reasoning; the premise pre-susposes the conclusion. This is a frequent logic error of both devout Athiests and devout Christians/Muslims/Jews/etc. This is an equally valid and flawed question; Are people unable to feel the presence and glory of God mentally ill?

Who is more sane; the kid who believes (or pretends to believe) in Santa Claus and gets lots of loot or the kid who denies Santa and gets nothing? The reality of Santa is moot. I suggest that the only thing that matters is results. Religion works to order society. Take it away and the mob will tear itself to pieces.