Cookie-Cutter Extracurriculars

TheGFG
Fri, 02 May 2008 18:21:42 +0000

Actually, the concept of a “competitive” music program is one about which some concerned parents have complained, but to no avail. The emphasis is placed on competition more than on the exposure to the enriching experience of music. Consequently, the dabblers and explorers feel the program is not for them–it’s for the “crazies”.

Individually, competition means working one’s way up to the higher level school bands and ensembles, and then also being accepted to the various regional and state-level groups. Corporately, it means achieving the highest honors at concert and jazz band festivals, and being chosen for special national recognition (for ex. there’s some event in Indiana to which only 16 or so of the best high school bands are invited.)

So, the casual or unskilled musician finds himself treated badly enough that he quits the program.