Free Trip to Israel

MidwestMom2Kids_1
Mon, 19 Dec 2011 07:41:28 +0000

doughmom:

I think all are being a bit harsh to OP. D is currently on the trip, and depending on the organizer they are quite loose about Jewishness. D has a Jewish mother, and Catholic father and has never practiced any religion, but that’s part of what they’re looking for - an opportunity to expose non-practicing Jews to Israel and Judaism.



I thought the same as doughmom, that Birthright liked to “expose non-practicing Jews to Israel” (and Judaism, too of course). Several of D’s friends had amazing experiences with their Birthright trips. I would have guessed that Birthright admins wouldn’t consider a non-religious young person without a Jewish mother to be considered an eligible non-practicing Jew, but since they are willing to allow him to apply, I think it is ok for him to apply.

I would not particularly encourage him to apply now. He does not seem particularly likely to benefit from this trip at this point in his life. And - as has been pointed out - he is not very likely to be accepted.

He sounds more likely to enjoy a YFU -sponsored Gap year or semester in Norway.