Penn M&T vs. CMU SCS

Much2learn
Sat, 28 Mar 2015 18:37:49 +0000

They are both excellent schools, but the experiences will be somewhat different. You really need to visit both schools and see what is right for you.

My impression is that students who are very focussed on Computer Science will typically choose CMU. Students who have broader interests such as combining Computer Science into an integrated program along with other interests, such as science, mathematics, networks, operations and information management, or sciences are more likely to choose Penn. Often a student’s interests evolve and Penn gives students good flexibility to shift among related fields.

The research opportunities at Penn are extensive during the year and also during the summer, but I can’t compare that to CMU. In general, Penn students have a high ability to transfer to other schools, but tend to stay at Penn because they like it. You are also free to take graduate courses as part of your undergraduate degree, as long as you meet the prerequisites.

As far as work load, DD is currently a CS major at Penn, and reports that she averages about 40 hours per week of homework on a non-test week. Adding in the scheduled class, recitation, and lab time, and she spends about 60 hours per week on school. It is challenging but manageable, and allows her to have some balance between academics, social activities and a couple of clubs and some volunteer work. She manages her schedule very efficiently. I do not know how that compares to CMU.

I think it is also important to visit and decide where you feel more comfortable socially. I can’t really compare these because I haven’t been to CMU and I don’t know your personality. There is a lot more to college than just academics. You will be there a long time.

I hope that helps some.