SCS vs Columbia Fu

somecsguy
Fri, 04 Apr 2008 16:04:49 +0000

I can’t exactly speak as to the specifics of the engineering program here, but SCS at CMU is very highly regarded and the opportunities afforded by such a program are huge. The main robotics program at CMU is graduate-level, but there is a minor and many related engineering courses, as well as student-organizations like the robotics club.

As far as liberal arts are concerned, I’ve found it quite easy to take classes in just about any area that I’m interested in, although if you want to focus on technical classes after completing gen-ed stuff, that’s also possible. I’m not up to date on all the gen-ed requirements from the other colleges, but SCS has a pretty flexible system in that regard. CMU also highly touts its interdisciplinary nature, with its blending of arts, sciences, engineering, and what-not – this facet is certainly present here, although occasionally the segmented nature of the individual colleges can get in the way.

As for deciding between CMU and Columbia, there is a significant difference, I suppose, between NYC and Pittsburgh. Personally, I really enjoy Pittsburgh, but I would highly advise you to actually visit CMU and get a feel for the environment yourself – there really is nothing like first-hand experience.

Good luck on making a decision!