Who is more likely to become an engineer?

Fredjan
Tue, 25 Nov 2014 05:15:50 +0000

Let’s say both students attend high schools where their quality of students is equal.

Student 1
Within the top 10% of his class, SAT>2000, very strong in Math and Science (5s on AP tests and A+ on honors/AP courses), has won some regional awards in Maths competitions, has never been exposed to engineering during his K-12 education nor does he know anything about programming, computers, and is definitely not a tinkerer or a hands-on person.
Will attend the state’s flagship.

Student 2, from magnet high school:
Top 25-40% of his class. Average SAT (not higher than 1700). All normal courses. Engineering has always been his dream. Interests include computer programming and tinkering; could built a well-functioning robot on his own. Posseses basic knowledge of carpentry and soldering.
Will attend the local satellite university.

Who is more likely to finish an Engineering degree?