I enrolled 4/25 and my first choice was Max P (relatively private bathrooms, I like the architecture, close to the gym + rest of campus, apparently well sound-proofed). My chances at getting that don't seem high, though, so I'm debating the order of my next two dorm choices.
I'm generally a quiet (but not unfriendly) person who prefers small get-togethers of friends to parties. This is something that would, as far as I can tell, put me in BJ territory.
On the other hand, I'm more fond of modern architecture and natural light, and new facilities, which puts me in South Campus territory.
I'm also kind of unenthusiastic about BJ dorms (I'm going by this: https://blogs.uchicago.edu/collegeadmissions/2009/02/dorm_of_the_day_burtonjudson.html
) and the South Campus ones seem nicer (and this is the only picture I have of them: http://www.uchicago.edu/i/features/main/20090928_south_dorm11.jpg
Comments, anyone? I'm especially interested in anyone who lived in South Campus, since I can't find much info about it. True that it's a loud, party-heavy place?