Welcome to College Confidential!

The leading college-bound community on the web

Sign Up For Free

Join for FREE, and start talking with other members, weighing in on community discussions, and more.

Also, by registering and logging in you'll see fewer ads and pesky welcome messages (like this one!)

As a CC member, you can:

  • Reply to threads, and start your own.
  • Post reviews of your campus visits.
  • Find hundreds of pages of informative articles.
  • Search from over 3 million scholarships.
wtr008wtr008 Registered User Posts: 61 Junior Member
So I've been accepted to UM and the University of Illinois- Urbana/Champaign. I got into the engineering school for both of them and I'm considering studying mechanical or biomedical engineering. I've already visited UM and loved it, but I haven't seen UI yet. I will visit both in mid-March, but I was wondering what you guys thought. Is one better than the other? Or about the same? And would I like one alot more than the other? The tuition for both should be about the same or a little less for UM (I got a scholarship). If anyone who knows about both Universities could give me an unbiased comparison I would greatly appreciate it. Thanks
Post edited by wtr008 on
«13

Replies to: UM or UI

  • j89j89 Registered User Posts: 1,103 Senior Member
    This decision's actually really difficult, if you're going to apply OOS for both of them. Engineering wise UIUC is slightly better, although the overall academics at UM is slightly better than UIUC. So academics (i would say) are at the same level. as for financial rates, I'm pretty sure UIUC and UM would offer similar tuition fees.. so financially they're almost the same. Sports... are also the same, although UM is (i think) more school-spirited. So in the end, I would say that it all depends on which campus you enjoy. Check out the dorms, people, classes, clubs/activities, etc, and see which one matches you better. But, hard choice anyways.
  • MightyNickMightyNick Registered User Posts: 2,097 Senior Member
    UM is better than UI overall. For engineering, both are equal. Go to whichever is cheaper.
  • SachmoneySachmoney Registered User Posts: 1,254 Senior Member
    UM has a BME program, UIUC does not. UM has a better ranked MechE program but it's 4 and 5...so what's the big difference. They're pretty evenly matched in engineering in my opinion. UIUC is probably slightly better overall. You can't go wrong either way. I would go to the school that was cheaper/offered a better undergraduate experience.
  • vc08vc08 Registered User Posts: 3,340 Senior Member
    on the west coast, and probably world-wide, Michigan definitely has a more notable academic rep. Both are good schools, but in the end, unless you find a significant difference in the campus tastes, etc., i'd go UMich
  • AlexandreAlexandre Registered User Posts: 24,693 Senior Member
    CAMPUS: Both universities have relatively nice campuses. Michigan's is less uniform but more impressive looking. Michigan's campus is also more lively. Edge Michigan.

    TOWN: Ann Arbor is a quaint, lively, intellectual, relatively wealthy college town with its fair share of fortune 500 companies and a thriving high tech/biotech industry. Urbana-Champaign are small, rural and traditionally farming communities. However, in recent years, there has been am emerging high tech industry. Again, the edge goes to Ann Arbor.

    LOCATION: Ann Arbor is 20 miles away from an international airport and 40 miles away from Downtown Detroit. Although the city of Detroit isn't much to look at, it offers the amenities that come with any major metropolotan area. The closest international airport or metropolitan area to Urbana-Champaign is Chicago, with si roughly 150 miles away. Edge goes to Michigan.

    ENGINEERING: In terms of overall Engineering rankings, Illinois is ranked anywhere from #4 and #6 in the nation. Michigan is ranked anywhere from #4 and #8 in the nation. For Mechanical Engineering, Michigan is generally ranked anywhere from #2 and #5 in the nation and Illinois is ranked anywhere from #3 and #5 in the nation. For Biomedical Engineering, Michigan is usually ranked between #8 and #10 in the nation and Illinois is not ranked among the top 20. For Engineering, Michigan and UIUC are roughly the same, but I don't think UIUC has a Biomedical Engineering program.

    OVERALL ACADEMICS: In the Sciences, particularly Chemistry and Physics, the slight edge goes to UIUC. In Engineering, Michigan and UIUC are even. In the Humanities, Social Sciences and Business, the edge goes to Michigan. Overall, Michigan is more well-rounded. Edge Michigan.

    RESCOURCES: UIUC has the third largest university-owned and operated library in the World. Michigan has the 7th largest university-owned and operated library in the World. Both universities have world-class, state-of-the-arts labs and facilities. Michigan's endowment stands at $7 billion (tied with Columbia) as the 6th wealthiest university in the US. UIUC has an endowment of $2 billion. Both schools have huge budgets ($1.5 billion/year).

    PROFESSIONAL/GRADUATE SCHOOL PLACEMENT: Engineers at both universities are heavily recruited by all sorts of tech/manufacturing companies. However, when it comes to recruitment by exclusive firms, such as the elite Aerospace, Investment Banking, Consulting firms, Michigan tends to be more heavily recruited. A degree from both universities will be highly respected by adcoms accross the academic world, but somehow, Michigan places a significantly higher portion of its students into top graduate schools. Edge Michigan, but in the case of Engineering firms and Engineering graduate programs, both schools do equally well.

    INTELLECTUAL ENVIRONMENT/ACADEMIC INTENSITY/ARTISTIC OFFERINGS: Michigan has top ranked Art, Music and Dance programs, attracting some of the most talented students in those disciplines. Furthermore, Ann Arbor (and Detroit) attract some of the finest artists and musicians from around the World to perform on or near the campus. Michigan's Hill Auditorium is one of the most acoustically perfect music halls in the country and is booked years in advance to host some of the most gifted musicians in the World. The Michigan Museum of Art, which is currently undergoing major construction work to double its size, is home to some incredible and internationally recognized works of art and exhibits. The campus's academic and intellectual energy is truly astounding and permeates every aspect of campus and city life. Furthermore, Ann Arbor's proximity to Detroit provides students with several world-class institutions, exhibitions, sporting/artisitic and musical events. UIUC has similar properties, but not in the same scale. Edge Michigan.

    SPORTS/SCHOOL SPIRIT: Historically, Michigan's Football and Hockey programs are unbeatable. Fans of the sports programs are ridiculously spirited. UIUC has a fine Football and Basketball history, but not to the same extent as Michigan. Edge Michigan.

    ALUMNI: UIUC can claim Hugh Hefner. Edge, UIUC! Seriously, both schools have huge and successful alumni bases. UIUC can claim Jack Welch (ex GE CEO and arguably the most effetive CEO ever). Michigan has its share of notable alums, including Google founder Larry Page and US President Gerald Ford. Michigan's top ranked MBA, Medical and Law programs provide the university with a very large and very wealthy alumni base. Alums from both universities are as loyal as they come, but Michigan alumni base is more spreadout, more diverse accross professional, ethnic, social, economic and geographic lines. For that reason, I give the edge to Michigan.

    In short, UIUC is a fine university, but Michigan edges it out in most respects.
  • SachmoneySachmoney Registered User Posts: 1,254 Senior Member
    I was going to add from reading Alexandre's post. If you go to college and decide that engineering isn't for you, Michigan offers more to fall back on. Michigan is so well rounded where you wouldn't have to transfer.
  • vc08vc08 Registered User Posts: 3,340 Senior Member
    Wow Alexander, that was very informative! Thanks, I'm not even considering UIUC, but I found that very helpful ;)
  • A2Wolves6A2Wolves6 Registered User Posts: 4,232 Senior Member
    Michigan's tuition = 31,301
    Illinois' tuition = 11,130
    Difference = 20,171

    Michigan, in the long run, will end up costing 80,000 more than Illinois.

    It would be idiotic to pay 80,000 more for what is essentially seen as the same engineering degree.
  • bennisbennis Registered User Posts: 351 Member
    Yeah, if cost is an issue, I would go with UI
  • dsmodsmo Registered User Posts: 1,749 Senior Member
    Go to whichever is the best value financially (cheapest.)
  • AlexandreAlexandre Registered User Posts: 24,693 Senior Member
    A2Wolves, compare apples to apples. You listed in-state tuition for Illinois and out-of-state tuition for Michigan. For out of staters, Illinois costs $25,000 to Michigan's $30,000. Michigan simply isn't that much more expensive than Illinois. And the OP clearly stated in the opening post:

    ..."The tuition for both should be about the same or a little less for UM (I got a scholarship)..."

    Now I agree that spending $80,000 more on a university degree (even a Harvard or MIT degree) when the alternative is a school of UIUC's calibre is definitely "idiotic". However, in this case, Michigan and Illinois will cost the OP roughly the same.
  • vc08vc08 Registered User Posts: 3,340 Senior Member
    yeah, A2 wolves' post was really deceiving...
  • bennisbennis Registered User Posts: 351 Member
    haha, I didn't even read that. Since cost isn't an issue disregard my previous post. =)
  • muzicgirl89muzicgirl89 Registered User Posts: 422 Member
    hmm, well I'm in Illinois so it certainly puts things in perspective for me, lol. I'm dearly hoping that some of my demonstrated need will be met by out of state schools like Michigan or Wisconsin though. My EFC is about 18,000 for federal methology and 13,000 for institutional according to calculations, and I'm hoping that doesn't all translate into loans.
  • wtr008wtr008 Registered User Posts: 61 Junior Member
    well thank you all for telling me all of this. ill probably go with UM because it has a biomed. engineering program and ill have more to fall back on if things dont work out. overall though, its a hard choice. im still visiting both in march.
This discussion has been closed.