Welcome to College Confidential!

The leading college-bound community on the web

Sign Up For Free

Join for FREE, and start talking with other members, weighing in on community discussions, and more.

Also, by registering and logging in you'll see fewer ads and pesky welcome messages (like this one!)

As a CC member, you can:

  • Reply to threads, and start your own.
  • Post reviews of your campus visits.
  • Find hundreds of pages of informative articles.
  • Search from over 3 million scholarships.

"Those ECs are weak...."- So what's good?


Replies to: "Those ECs are weak...."- So what's good?

  • theringoinfinitetheringoinfinite Registered User Posts: 120 Junior Member
    edited May 2016
    I will likely be participating in a breast cancer research project at a large public university for 2-3 days a week for 8 weeks this summer. Is this a good EC if I'm interested in biological sciences?
  • JasmineArmaniJasmineArmani Registered User Posts: 124 Junior Member
    edited May 2016
    @FernErny I feel you Ferny. This sites sometimes make sad because I see all these achievements and awards/ championships my counterparts have achieved and I haven't even come close :( Makes me not even want to pursue my dream school anymore because it seems like I have NO chance.
  • hitmeisterhitmeister Registered User Posts: 12 New Member
    It's hard to tell if this is a serious reply or a satirical one. Sure, any of those things would be great, you don't need to be that type of super achiever to get into a top school.. All the top schools repeatedly state that they're looking for students who are passionate about something. A "list" of ECs is far less impressive than a single EC that demonstrates true passion. And it doesn't really matter what that activity is as long as it's something the student truly loves and is dedicated to.

    If you go to the website of any elite school, you'll probably see the word "passion" or "passionate" in the section about admissions. I don't see any reason to think they're lying about this. I interview high school seniors on behalf of an Ivy League school. it's the same thing the admissions office tells the interviewers to look for.
  • AlexanderHamil2kAlexanderHamil2k Registered User Posts: 10 New Member
    My EC's include:
    Starting up my own club with some friends at school, Floor Hockey Club; meant to get kids active.
    Participating in FBLA and Model U.N state competitions
    Making sandwiches for the homeless with my local Beta Club
    Outside of School:
    Volunteer at my nearby retirement/nursing home every week (over summer and school)
    Volunteering at my church (over summer)
    Working a part-time job over the summer, might be too busy to continue it through Senior Year

    I know it doesn't compare to the Perfect Soldier EC's that the Harvard kids have, but there aren't many opportunities where I'm at. School is very well off so they don't have any money issues, that being said the school is very bureaucratic (took us the whole semester to get FHL approved) so I can't start some sort of volunteer group of superheroes at my school. I'm also focused on living a life, so as interested as I am in Astrophysics, I don't want to spend my whole ding dong diddly summer at Kennedy Space Station for a NASA program.

    I know, as I have been told many times, my EC's are weaker than a man on life support, but I can't think of anything outside of going to my local Town Hall and running for office to make myself stand out.
  • ushnizushniz Registered User Posts: 16 New Member
    How would you guys rate my EC's?
    Head of the student council
    Was the event head for the school's anniversary, basically did all the work including organizing and sorting out all the kids into teams, organized the stalls and arranged all the things needed)
    Volunteered at my city's TedX
    Ran the school's cafeteria for a week with my classmates, the proceedings went to charity
    Organizer at my school's yearly Olympic games (2 years)
    Organizer at my school's MUN
    2 Paid Internships
    100 Hours of community service
    Currently filming a documentary on children of the slums for an NGO
    Going to start our own fundraiser for children's books and stuff with a few of my friends
    Planning on attending Stanford's summer program next summer
    Will participate in MUNs and different competitions in the coming year

    Also, if i may add I live in a developing country in South Asia so I didn't really get many chances to participate in a lot of things.
  • ushnizushniz Registered User Posts: 16 New Member
    Also, forgot to include that I was a part of the Art club for 2 years and the Music club for a year.
  • RoadTriptoCollege2017RoadTriptoCollege2017 Registered User Posts: 166 Junior Member
    "Only as good as your scores" - no offense but this is kind of ignorant, maybe up to a point but ivy leagues are more about fit and essays than scores of you are decently well off
  • almondine15almondine15 Registered User Posts: 22 New Member
    Also be sure to do a great job writing about your ECs in your essay :)
  • thirsty4ivythirsty4ivy Registered User Posts: 7 New Member
    From my research (I'm not an expert), the best EC's are what you are truly passionate about and to go as far as you possibly can with that passion. If you like research, do summer research and win competitions to show you're commitment and acheivment in that passion
  • TheYellowBiscuitTheYellowBiscuit Registered User Posts: 103 Junior Member
    This article is great. Thanks for creating it.
  • SomedayIwillSomedayIwill Registered User Posts: 98 Junior Member
    You have a laundry list of random EC's, which isn't necessarily bad, but just by reading it I get the sense that you're trying to list out as many accomplishments as you can. Pick a subject you're passionate about and eliminate everything else. And create a thread if you want more response.
  • kmurphy1845kmurphy1845 Registered User Posts: 8 New Member
    @Northstarmom I am a student in Mississippi who doesn't have a huge list of "fabulous" ECs. However, I have been involved in my school districts advanced choirs since the 5th grade, gotten into the state honor choir every year I've auditioned, and gotten into an elite girls auditioned choir. I'm section leader and a shoe in for chamber queen of my madrigal group.
    I've also volunteered 650+ hours at a state hospital, and I want to go into medical/forensic anthropology in college. Do you think that these are good ECs?
  • Isabel2017Isabel2017 Registered User Posts: 33 Junior Member
    Your ECs show commitment and passion. You are clearly not a dilettante who tries a bit of everything and is good at none. 650 hours of one thing shows dedication. Specifically it supports your interest in the medical field, so it all lines up. I would write a thoughtful and well edited essay that highlights where your passion lies and what you plan to study; then sit back and trust that it'll get you Into a "good fit" school. All the best to you!
  • ZealousScholarZealousScholar Registered User Posts: 239 Junior Member
    I know ECs don't have any set ranking, but I have a question about a particular EC that I haven't really seen on CC. I did an independent research project and it went all the way to Intel ISEF. How much weight does it carry to be an Intel ISEF finalist? Does it compare to a summer research program? Or is it considered a merit/award? (I believe around 1,700 are selected from all around the world each year).
  • OneNormalKnightOneNormalKnight Registered User Posts: 153 Junior Member
    Are my EC's very weak? I am about to be a junior.

    Drama - since freshman year. Involved in 2 musicals (dance/chorus), 1 straight play (supporting), 3 one-acts (1 supporting, 2 main).
    Cross country - since freshman year. JV both years. I have worked very hard to get to where I am now and it could be an essay topic.
    Golf - since sophomore year. I'm not very good but I made my varsity letter and I am working to get better.
    Volunteering - since sophomore summer. I've gone on two mission trips, one to Haiti and one to Nicaragua. I'm really proud of the Nicaragua trip - we did construction work at an orphanage for kids with special needs, it was an amazing experience. I also helped with a golf clinic for underprivileged kids.

    I will hopefully have more prominent roles in school plays as a junior and senior. I am going to be an officer next year (historian, basically managing social media and documenting club activities) for my school's thespian chapter. I will probably run for chapter president as a senior.
    When I started cross-country, I absolutely hated it. Now I love running; it is good for my mental health and just generally makes me feel good. I hope to run varsity the next two years. If I'm successful, I have a chance at becoming a team captain.
    My golf team is small and I hope to be captain or co-captain my junior and/or senior year.
    I am trying to start a Science Olympiad team at my school. If I am successful, I will probably be captain my junior and senior year.
    I am going to be doing a LOT more volunteering since I know that is probably the weakest part of my resume. I will be volunteering with the Red Cross a few hours a week (as much as I can manage honestly), as well as with my church (Sunday school for kids who are converting to Catholicism, 4 hours/week + mentoring special needs kids for my youth group, 2 hours/week).

    Any suggestions?
    Should I join a service organization? My school's Beta chapter only allows members to log hours from club-sponsored events... would I be better off keeping track of my hours independently?
    Thank you!
This discussion has been closed.