She is not being “attacked”. Simply pointing out that “clueless” really should have been titled “clued in”.
The threads are supposedly about a clueless high school student who did what made him happy rather than pursue activities that might clue one in to what creates a attractive college application & yet, surprise, gets admitted to the number one ranked LAC in the nation.
Yet this was a hooked applicant to that school who had the savvy to apply ED to benefit from being a legacy. The “clueless” applicant also spent a great deal of time & resources on college application activities that probably left little time for much else in the way of ECs. Essentially the college search & application process was this young man’s primary EC. This was a privileged student who had devoted parental guidance.
By the time he applied, he probably had the equivalent of a PhD in college admissions.
I find it humorous & charming, and informative, as presented by the poster.