We have changed the way we log in on College Confidential. Read more here.
Is a strong Biology background a pre-requisite for O Chem/O Chem II?
LanaHere
607 replies31 threads Member
My D is a first year Chem E major with BioE concentration and premed track. She has a full schedule this past semester (fall 2014) and this semester (spring 2015), so she's putting off taking College Biology, a premed required class. Unfortunately, next semester (fall 2015- her sophomore year), her schedule will be full with Engineering classes PLUS Organic Chemistry, so taking Bio is out of the question, unless she drops a class or take 21 credit hours. I think for a STEM major 21 credit hours per semester is too heavy of a course load.
Her other options: Take Bio over the summer at a Community College (which is not recommended by premed advisor) or take Bio in Spring 2016 (her Sophomore year). The only thing is, Spring 2016, she'll be in Organic Chemistry II.
My question: How much Biology should she have prior to enrolling in O Chem II? Does O Chem I & O Chem II require a strong background in Biology?
Please note: She took AP Biology in high school in 11th grade, but no Biol lectures since then. However, she has 3 summers of Research Lab (working with cells) work experience under her belt. But we all know Lab is lab and not actual Biology classes.
Thank you.
25 replies Her other options: Take Bio over the summer at a Community College (which is not recommended by premed advisor) or take Bio in Spring 2016 (her Sophomore year). The only thing is, Spring 2016, she'll be in Organic Chemistry II.
My question: How much Biology should she have prior to enrolling in O Chem II? Does O Chem I & O Chem II require a strong background in Biology?
Please note: She took AP Biology in high school in 11th grade, but no Biol lectures since then. However, she has 3 summers of Research Lab (working with cells) work experience under her belt. But we all know Lab is lab and not actual Biology classes.
Thank you.
This discussion has been closed.
Replies to: Is a strong Biology background a pre-requisite for O Chem/O Chem II?
Isn't Biology a full year?
These are the classes:
Biology (Genes, Evolution & Ecology) is a 1 semester course.
Cells and Proteins- One semester.
Biochem - One semester.
O Chem I- One semester
O Chem II- One semester.
O chem labs I & II - Two semester.
1 Biology lab- One semester.
The school has it in this order: Biology (Genes, Evolution and Ecology) - Fall 2014.
Biology (Cells and Proteins): Junior Fall (which will be Fall 2017 for my D).
I was wondering if you and other CC folks can give your opinion on this:
Premed advisor had said DO NOT take premed classes at a community college. But given that Biology is a lower level premed required class, and not O Chem I, II or Biochem, do you think Medical School's Admin won't be to hard on her application if she'll take Biology (Genes & Evolution) at a community college?
I know other criteria go into her application: GPA, MCAT etc.. and not just where did you take your first Biology class.
Thanks.
Biology is a cakewalk. If she's had AP Biology she should be in good shape.
What does she do in the laboratory with cells?
Thank You for that JustOneDad.
I checked and Biology (Genes and Evolution) are offered both semesters, fall and spring. I guess because this is a research school so there are a lot of Bio majors.
She assisted MSTP students with their research..
She set up their experiments and did things that required her to use SDS-PAGE, Western Blots, Imuno-Cyto-Chemistry Methods, splitting cells and more things that are over my head.
I am not a Biology person so I am just going by what I was told. If I said something that didn't make sense, please forgive me.
Thanks
Yes, Cells and Proteins is Fall Junior year, which is 2016... I wrote the wrong year earlier.
She is from the class of 2018. So MCAT test will be during spring 2017 for her.
So what happened? Did she take the exam? Did she get a 5? If so, why take high school bio again? Take something more interesting, e.g. immunology, cell, genetics, physio, anatomy, etc.
@plumazul
You don't need any biology for organic chemistry, unless your daughter's school lists lists it as a prerequisite for some reason.
It's generally recommend not to take premed courses at a community college because it's often seen as an easier course than taking it at a 4-year university, regardless of if that's actually true or not. It's safer to take it at her 4-year university if she is able to just to take that worry off the table. If she chooses the take intro bio at the community college, I'd recommend she take more advanced bio classes at her university to demonstrate that she is able to do well in more difficult biology classes at her university and to counteract any possible negative perceptions. Since medical school admissions are already so hyper competitive, the thinking is often that it's just not a risk worth taking if she can avoid it.
While many medical schools have restrictions on what AP credits you can use (if you can use any at all), more advanced courses are accepted in place of the intro versions. Many premed students take more advanced biology courses regardless because of their major or just out of interest, so in the case of AP Biology, this is often not a cause of concern for most premed majors. She could have taken the AP test and then taken more advanced biology classes at her school. There's nothing you can do about it now, but it's always good to know things.
Oh good heavens. I wish that people who gave such stupid advice understood what med schools want and don't want.
For non-premeds, do you really need Biology (Genes, Evolution & Ecology) to understand Cells & Proteins?
My D is doing BME and to meet her Natural Science requirements, she must take a Biology class (any class from 100 level to 400 level). Since BME courses have a lot of biology and medical applications, is it wise just to skip Genes and Evolution & Ecology, and go straight to Cells & Proteins?
One less class to take.