Make sure to check out our July Checklists for HS Juniors and HS Seniors. Consult these quick resources to get you started on the process this month.
GUEST STUDENT OF THE WEEK: ehales3 is a rising sophomore at Cornell University. As a high school student, she always thought that she wanted to study in a more urban environment, but has grown to love Ithaca and all that it offers. ASK HER ANYTHING!
As we work to adjust to the current reality, make sure to check out these dedicated COVID-19 resources: our directory of virtual campus tours, our directory of extended deadlines, as well as the list of schools going test optional this fall.
Full Pay Families Pay For Aid & Scholarships??
CupCakeMuffins
1156 replies113 threads Senior Member
Is this true? Is this the reason behind high cost?
“At private colleges, you should ask, “What is the school’s tuition discount rate?” These discounts are actually tuition dollars that families or students pay that are redistributed – for very good reasons – to support students with high financial need or to attract students with special talents. “
https://www.google.com/amp/s/theconversation.com/amp/5-ways-to-check-a-colleges-financial-health-127908
32 replies “At private colleges, you should ask, “What is the school’s tuition discount rate?” These discounts are actually tuition dollars that families or students pay that are redistributed – for very good reasons – to support students with high financial need or to attract students with special talents. “
https://www.google.com/amp/s/theconversation.com/amp/5-ways-to-check-a-colleges-financial-health-127908
Replies to: Full Pay Families Pay For Aid & Scholarships??
My guess is that, in general, schools with really large endowments don't redistribute tuition dollars to families will get need based aid. I guess it's good to know. If it bothers a family paying full price then they would consider where their money is going but a good point is made that diversity is a good thing and it benefits the full pay kids too.
While spending per student is certainly linked to endowment, there are schools with less than $10B endowments where spending per student is greater than all in costs.
Bowdoin, for example, spends more per student than COA.
Here is a link that shows 6 of the 10 LAC NESCACs where per student spend > COA, and some of them have <$1B endowments. https://bowdoinorient.com/2019/04/12/how-does-bowdoin-spend-its-money/
Wrt the article that OP posted, it is important to look at the financial health of any school on your kid's list. At some schools, the full pays do subsidize those receiving aid.
There's a great blog called higher ed data stories. There is an illuminating analysis of average discount rate by school (one measure of financial health), posted on Mar 27, 2019. It uses 2016 data from IPEDs which is still the most recent data available.
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.forbes.com/sites/prestoncooper2/2017/02/22/how-unlimited-student-loans-drive-up-tuition/amp/
Several recent studies have found evidence that other federal student aid programs drive of tuition increases. A 2015 study found that a dollar of subsidized (non-PLUS) student loans increases published tuition by 58 cents at a typical college, with larger effects once reductions in institutional financial aid are taken into account. An NBER paper issued last year concluded that changes to federal student loans are more than sufficient to explain tuition increases at private nonprofit colleges. And a 2014 analysis found that for-profit colleges eligible for federal student aid charged tuition 78% higher than that of similar but aid-ineligible institutions.
Like I said, elite schools either use endowment for financial aid and/or they will always have plenty of full pay families because families deem it “worth it” to go to those schools.
Nobody has all the answers but with your logic, either most schools would've to stop giving aid or close shop.
Choices choices.
We were able to be full pay...you know what? I don’t give two hoots if my kids’ colleges used part of what I paid to help fund financial aid for needy students, or for merit aid for students. I think that’s not a bad thing at all. It helps colleges get at least a little more well rounded classes of students.
If you don’t want your money to go to paying for others, then there are lots of things you need to stop paying...lots. But let’s nit go there unless you want this thread closed.
Like I said...I feel fortunate to be in the financial position our family is in. Oh...and we also make annual donations to where we got our degrees and to the schools our kids attended.
Or you’re concerned that some of the money paid by full pay families helps pay for financial aid for families who need it?
"If paying families would go elsewhere and cost would need downward readjustment to keep getting paying students then how are those colleges going to fund financial aid?"
And indeed, virtually all colleges besides the richest few do not guarantee to meet full need for everyone.
Meanwhile, the most elite privates could fill their student body several times over will full-payers if they wanted to because the demand is that high.
So here's what seems curious to me, @CupCakeMuffins:
You've been on the CC boards for a few years now. Are you saying you just figured out the economics of higher ed in the US? I find that mystifying.
So even if $3,500 of subsidized federal direct loans increases tuition by $2,030, that is very little of the $55,000 or so list price tuition at the private universities and LACs that people on these forums focus on.
Costs are rising on the top end because the demand for the elites are insanely strong and come from all over the world. And demand is insanely strong because of rising inequality in the US and rise of the upper-middle-class/rich all over the world where they didn't exist before. Getting rid of subsidized federal loans will barely make a dent in the COA of the Ivies/equivalents.
If you really cared about affordability for everyone, then I'm sure you'd support free college for everyone. Of course, the funding would still have to come from somewhere: Taxpayers
Are you afraid you might be paying toward somebody else and don't want to? What's the point?