Welcome to College Confidential!

The leading college-bound community on the web

Sign Up For Free

Join for FREE, and start talking with other members, weighing in on community discussions, and more.

Also, by registering and logging in you'll see fewer ads and pesky welcome messages (like this one!)

As a CC member, you can:

  • Reply to threads, and start your own.
  • Post reviews of your campus visits.
  • Find hundreds of pages of informative articles.
  • Search from over 3 million scholarships.

May 1st is around - Emory Vs Rice

stan2011stan2011 Registered User Posts: 11 New Member
edited May 2011 in Emory University
My son got admitted to both Emory and Rice. At this time, he wants to major in Biochemistry with possible pre-med (not 100% sure at this time). We visited both colleges in the last 2 weeks and not able to decide between them. He looked at different factors like, look of campus, classroom setting, dorms, weather, food, student social life and came to a conclusion that any one will fit for him. From financials point of view there is not much difference in family contribution amount, so it is not a deciding factor. We drove around a bit both in Huston and Atlanta during our visit. Again it is a tie. So, it came down to how good Biochemstry dept is at these schools and pre-professional advising/support available at these schools. Provide your opinion from these 2 points of view and any other information that will help us decide.
Post edited by stan2011 on
«1

Replies to: May 1st is around - Emory Vs Rice

  • hsu0216hsu0216 Registered User Posts: 20 New Member
    The CDC is in Emory. That, in and of itself, is fantastic for ALL SORTS of research. Not only that, but Emory is highly involved in research as an institution.

    Rankings & Successes: Breakthrough Research | Emory University | Atlanta, GA

    You may want to look at Rice's research offerings.

    Both colleges probably offer fantastic pre-med curricula that you really can't go wrong with. There are brilliant individuals in both colleges, and I know people always say this, but at these top 20 universities, the difference is not in the facility offerings (though they can vary a significant amount) but rather the student's willingness and dedication to finding these offerings.
    I would say Rice's and Emory's pre-med are of comparable standing. You're not going to have trouble getting into a dream medical program if your son works his butt off doing what he loves with all sorts of international and domestic volunteer and research.
  • stan2011stan2011 Registered User Posts: 11 New Member
    How hard or easy to get a 3.9 GPA for pre-med at Emory. Any current seniors/juniors comment on this
  • bernie12bernie12 Registered User Posts: 5,293 Senior Member
    It's pre-med at a top school, where will getting a 3.9 be easy? That's not going to happen at Rice or Emory if your son does not work very hard. Anything is possible. Plenty of pre-med folks here with 3.7+(some worked hard, lots chose easy courses/profs., w/e). Ideally, though, it should be challenging to get that GPA at either. If not, your son is wasting money. Also, hate to turn your son away from here, but we don't have a specific undergrad. biochem. dept. What I have done is major in chem and bio and it has served me well intellectually (my GPA is of course not a 3.9, I take really hard classes. I'm doing ok, but not a 3.9 or near it to be honest. It's closer to Emory's graduating average which isn't bad considering the classes I've been through). However, this won't be simple if you want a "3.9". If anything, just dabble in the chem and bio dept for courses of interests (the more bio focused courses in the chem. dept.). The chem. dept is somewhat brutal compared to the other science majors here, but it isn't undoable. Most pre-meds will generally wimp out and get a BA if they are also dabbling in biology.

    However, if you're like many (especially pre-meds) here and just want to make it look like you took hard classes and learned a lot, there are some profs. in both depts that I would recommend, but you really shouldn't waste your time (your son won't learn a thing from these folks). You might as well go to a non-flagship (and in some cases flagship, like UGA is surprisingly much easier than here for example) state school for this if you come to a top school to constantly worry about keeping a 3.9 GPA. It costs much less to do so at such places. And if you do that well at such an institution, you have just as much a chance at a dream med. school as an Emory student provided you do well on the MCAT (Emory offers no advantage here, hardly no school does. You either do well on standardized tests or not). Basically, this is me being blunt and saying that, if your son is to get his money's worth at either, he will need to take better profs. (which tend to be tougher) and will thus have to work hard to get the desired GPA. Hopefully this is an okay. A pre-med is wasting time if they came to slack off.

    As for grading, neither has low inflation-deflation if you are worried about. You generally get what you deserve or a bit higher in some cases, so it's tough but doable with dedication (and easy if you cheat like the pre-meds I allude to above. Yes I view taking "easy, easy, easy, easy" at a top school as cheating. They cheat themselves more than anything, both out of money and a higher MCAT).
  • shuimaoshuimao Registered User Posts: 11 New Member
    I will pick Rice
  • LichenloverLichenlover Registered User Posts: 21 New Member
    Shuimao: Rather than posting the same ungrammatical phrase over and over again in different threads, perhaps you could provide some information that supports your assertion.
  • texaspgtexaspg Forum Champion Pre-Med & Medical Posts: 16,713 Forum Champion
    3.9 GPA is a very hard target for biochemistry major in a top 20 school without some superhuman effort.
    Someone pointed out CDC is in Atlanta and attached to Emory. Rice sits in the middle of two medical schools and a world renowned medical center with every type of specialty hospital in walking distance.
  • bernie12bernie12 Registered User Posts: 5,293 Senior Member
    Lichen: Don't feed ****. Again, I'm sure the person would choose hell if it was a university so don't bother.
    Texas: I think they both have clout in the medicine area, so Rice nor Emory really has advantage there. In fact some may claim that our direct attachment to one plus the ties to Tech, Grady, and various other healthcare facilities/centers in the Atlanta area/Georgia is extremely advantageg school. A surprising amount of undergrads. here are getting on board with projects and interests in this realm, including pre-meds. . I mean, we run the largest healthcare system in the state. That plus clout in the public health realm provides quite an array of options Global/Public Health is essentially our substitute for the missing engineering component. Not to mention, many initial pre-meds maychange their mind. Many of my friends have good grades, but developed a very strong interest in service and public health efforts. Having heavy influence/connections with things that are healthcare related, but not directly related to medical practice could be beneficial. So Public Health School+CDC+Med. School+Healthcare System/Auxillaries+Tech gives great oppurtunities in an array of areas just as Rices proximity/connections to surrounding medical schools. So they basically tie again. I don't think that poster meant that Rice has nothing, they were simply saying that Emory has a strength on top of the norm/expected one when it comes to health related fields. Rice has engineering (having connections to a place like Tech is like having 1/2 an engineering school. It mainly improves research opps/prospects as Tech is excellent for engineering related research. If it wasn't Tech or a similar-higher caliber place it probably would matter much less), we have Public Health (as in these are key differences between the two as we both have heavy medical facility/school connects)
  • kp217kp217 Registered User Posts: 225 Junior Member
    Go to Emory

    Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using CC App
  • stan2011stan2011 Registered User Posts: 11 New Member
    Thanks every one for your feedback. My son paid deposit at Rice. He went back and forth between Emory and Rice. He used a numeric scale (every item is scored on 10 point scale) for: Major that he wants to major in, Academic Rigor, Research Opportunities, Grade Inflation/Deflation, Campus look and feel, Class room setup, Campus surrounding area, Food at dorms, Dorm Room, Career Center help and Pre-Professional Advising. Both schools scored almost the same with 1 point difference (Emory with advantage). Rice offered about 6K more in financial aid (In my original post, I mentioned that there is no difference in family contribution, to get the feedback on items other than money). In our OPINION, both are very similar schools (again, our opinion), with minor differences in each of those areas mentioned, but at the end we followed the money as other differences are so minor.
  • bernie12bernie12 Registered User Posts: 5,293 Senior Member
    I think that's fair. Smart decision. When schools are so similar, you should just go with the less expensive option. Good luck to the both of you.
  • Owl2014Owl2014 Registered User Posts: 141 Junior Member
    Rice is a better overall school than Emory and carries more prestige. Good decision!
  • emorydeacemorydeac Registered User Posts: 114 Junior Member
    More prestige among whom....certainly not in academia. Both are excellent schools and will provide you with many opportunities. I suspect Emory provides more research opportunities based upon the amount of funding each school receives for research. However, the primary difference is in cost and fit.
  • bernie12bernie12 Registered User Posts: 5,293 Senior Member
    Owl: You fail. You have no proof of that. The prestige is probably equal in the US, and generally Emory is probably known better outside of it because of its various public health, policy, and educational initiatives such as Tibet-Emory Science initiative and our "very" close connection to the Dalai Lama. I doubt you hardly know anything about Emory other than its rank so you should shut up. The academics are probably very similar for any fields shared between the two except that I hear the science/engineering scene at Rice almost completely overshadows the liberal arts. I heard this from my freshman roommate from Houston who considered Rice and chose Emory over it. He also sited some advantage in facilities, which if you look at architecture you can't tell, but he said the general condition of facilities here was much more consistent, whereas many Rice buildings only look solid on the outside. Emory still has a very alive and noticeable social science/humanities scene and certainly carries clout in that area. The prestige/influence difference is really not different enough to choose one over the other based upon just that. Also, Rice may have an advantage in the grade inflation area. He and another fellow Texan told me that they tend to inflate more like Ivies than top southern privates, so I imagine that must be nice.

    You must be an idiot if you really think that's enough to choose Rice over Emory. Even the rankings imply that we are more similar than we are different in terms of academics. Given their smaller size one would expect a huge advantage, but that clearly isn't the case. In fact our larger size may actually serve us well in terms of research ops. and internships.
    As for academia: Rice has always been great w/physics, math, engineering and stuff, while we do extremely well in medicine/healthcare and the natural and behavioral sciences (lots of ground breaking stuff in psychology, neuroscience, behavioral biology, which have lead to medical/pharmacological discoveries). So the two are awesome, but in different fields. Not to mention, many of the great researchers teach undergrads. and often "well", a rare quality for a place of Emory's size (like twice Rice's size, meaning that Rice better have this quality).
  • Colleges00701Colleges00701 - Posts: 1,790 Senior Member
    It's pre-med at a top school, where will getting a 3.9 be easy? That's not going to happen at Rice or Emory if your son does not work very hard. Anything is possible. Plenty of pre-med folks here with 3.7+(some worked hard, lots chose easy courses/profs., w/e).

    Getting at least a 3.7-3.8 is doable if you work hard. A lot of it depends on what professors you take.
«1
This discussion has been closed.