Best line (about Columbia): “Location in New York has little appeal to most students.”
That was also true 25 years later in the mid 1980’s when I was applying colleges. None of the top students at my public HS (on Long Island) wanted to go to Columbia, and the main reason was its location. I had a good friend (who did a 3/2 engineering degree with a SUNY school and Columbia) who was held up at gunpoint just off campus in the late 80s. Of course things are much different now and Columbia’s location is an asset.