Yes, thinking the same thing…they report full range of scores for all the scores they received from admitted students…which could contain multiple scores from any given admitted student.
Other random surmisings:
I am skeptical of the data, same as @JBFlying, despite the admissions officer telling me all data was correct and current.
Regarding why students with relatively low scores might choose to not apply TO:
—As above, could be multiple scores from a given applicant, with some being higher, perhaps significantly so.
—Another potential factor…there are many high schools especially those serving URM, low SES, and/or first gen students who don’t have GCs, or have less the competent one who might have had no idea UChicago was TO…really, this happens. It’s highly likely those low end scores for admitted students came from URMs, low SES and/or first gen applicants.
I didn’t ask if the score ranges on the profile were superscored…some (many?) schools that superscore do report superscored test stats on their profiles/CDSs, etc.
Also, even though recruited athletes can apply TO, I didn’t ask if they require a test score when doing the academic pre-read (some/many(?) TO schools do, and some/many(?) TO schools don’t allow athletes to apply TO)…if so, and this student ultimately applied TO, perhaps those test scores found their way in to the data as well.