I agree that some of the OP’s posts may seem as though they are being written by a youngster or parent in the midst of college search stress.
However, I lurk on some other forums, and in fact, the OP holds him/herself out as a guidance counselor (perhaps at a boarding school) or an independent college counselor. Here is just one example:
http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/discussion/comment/17764708/#Comment_17764708
I think the misinformation (nice euphemism) that has been cited in this thread and that has recently been pointed out in other recent threads here would be understandable…even if not excusable…for an applicant or an applicant’s parents. For it to be published by someone who holds him/herself out as a guidance counselor or independent college counselor is [fill in the blank]