@suzy100 and @socaldad2002 I actually think that studying for the PSAT (which is given in the fall of 11th as you know) can be accomplished by studying for the ACT - taking practice sections too. It all helps in timing and learning tricks/testing strategies, weaknesses and strengths. I would have your child study (with a tutor) and see which test she feels better with. If it is the SAT, then yes, have her take it after she takes the PSAT in the Fall (October I think). If she likes the ACT better, then have her prepare more for that type of test and timing. Have her take the PSAT (just in case she qualifies for NMerit) and then maybe in October or December take the ACT. Both my kids studied starting in the summer before 11th grade studying for the ACT - they are more of that kind of test taker. They studied and then right before the PSAT switched to take a few practice PSAT. They both took the ACT in the fall around same time as PSAT. I would not wait until early spring to take the ACT if needed (not sure what @suzy100 means by this). You can determine which test your kid likes better by having them take a practice of each at home and self grading (or having a tutor do that). The ACT is more straight forward and tests what you know. It is more of a time crunch though - some say. The SAT gives more time, but many say it is tricky.