NYU is lenient on SAT for students coming in from disadvantaged backgrounds via HEOP and other opportunity programs, but you have to be a NY state resident for these at NYU. Is there any way you can retake SAT? They will probably give you some leeway in comparing to your school profile, but I am not sure how much. And as others mentioned, financial aid could be an issue; there are very few who get a full ride at NYU and while aid is predominantly need-based for most, they generally don’t cover full need.
Also, in graduating one year early, how do your high school credits stack up against the recommended from NYU, where the most competitive candidates have 4 years in all these? https://www.nyu.edu/admissions/undergraduate-admissions/how-to-apply/all-freshmen-applicants/high-secondary-school-preparation.html