Advice on which colleges might meet our daughter’s criteria

Good questions :slight_smile:
Her high school is about 1500 students, so definitely at least that big. She thinks somewhere between 5,000 - 12,000 might be ideal, but with Covid stunting summer visits we haven’t actually visited any campuses in that range. We toured Harvard on vacation (more of a tourist visit), and walked around ASU on another trip. She’s also familiar with Iowa & Iowa State’s campuses - her comment about a “defined campus” is a result of liking ISU’s campus better than Iowa’s. She thinks for sure she doesn’t want a supersized school like Texas A&M; but if academics, scholarships, and the ability to find a smaller community within a large school prove to be a good fit I think she’d be open to larger than the 12,000 I mentioned. Similarly, that 5,000 isn’t a hard number on the low side either - but I know she doesn’t want a tiny school.

Public vs Private doesn’t really matter. As for the “vibe”, she’s not interested in a Greek system and doesn’t want a “party school” - though I’ve told her not everyone at the “party schools” are party hard. I think she’d like a laid back campus vibe. She’s casual, outdoorsy, likes to keep busy, spiritual, but not politically conservative.

I looked into these a few months ago, but haven’t revisited the subject. I’m worried about the program losing its state funding due to Covid, etc. Anyone know about the probability of that? I know there are other threads on that topic - I’ll have to find them again for updates.

FSU’s campus especially looks really nice, but DD isn’t sure about about spending 4 years in Florida. Maybe she’s seen too many “only in Florida” jokes/memes/vines. The DD of a family friend attends FSU - I need to have our DD talk to her about her experience.

Notre Dame has an environmental engineering major.

Santa Clara U is a Jesuit school that’s in a great location weather-wise. They’re very well regarded in the Bay area and are receiving a lot of new funding for STEM.

My straight A, 29 ACT, lots of community service, soft ball playing, science major, Iowa farm daughter niece ended up in the honors program at Guilford with serious merit-based aid. I have no idea how she found it. Maybe the Colleges that Change Lives list? She did not visit until after being accepted, at which point is was her most affordable of multiple admissions offers. She flew down to visit with my sister after being accepted, did a tour, and said, “I can be very happy here.” Which she was.

If money is an issue, your daughter’s best strategy for now is to have plenty of potentially affordable places that she’s “in like” with. When the admissions and aid packages are on the table next spring, that will be plenty of time to decide which is most worthy of her love.

I just used niche website to cross reference her preferred programs of study with automatic (or maybe “less competitive”) merit scholarship research I had done previously. None of these really fit into her smaller school category, but they do seem well rounded in Environmental Sci, Chem, Physics, Math, & Engineering. All of these seem worth at least digging into further:
UT-Austin (obviously big, but supposed to be good for outdoor enthusiasts too)
Florida
Texas A&M
FSU
USF (really? I was surprised they were ranked decent in 4 of the 5 programs)
Utah
Oklahoma
Alabama?
Arizona?
Miami, Oh?
Iowa State (ranked well in 3, but not Chem or Physics)
disappointed Washington St didn’t rank higher in anything but engineering - besides being far away seems like maybe her vibe (except for the rain :wink:

PS: These may be the start of “safety” schools to maybe become “in like” with a few. With her stats I think it will be worth trying for some more competitive scholarships at other schools as well. And, again, we need to figure out our budget - I know :smile:

My daughter sounds almost exactly like yours in terms of credentials, outdoorsy interests, and future interest in science. Mine is more into genetics and molecular biology.

Here in the Pacific Northwest we have explored virtually every option. If you are interested in this part of the country and want outdoorsy private schools with good academics and science offerings the ones to put on your list would be:

University of Puget Sound
Lewis & Clark College
Whitman College
Gonzaga University

Reed College (my alma matter) is a wildcard. It’s quirky place and almost obsessively and brutally academic to the exclusion of all else. They also don’t do merit aid so I’m not encouraging my kid to go there but will support her if it is really what she wants.

In terms of public schools, UW-Seattle is enormous and a cut above all the others. UO in Eugene is increasingly popular with Californians who don’t get into the UC system. But I"m not sure there are really any public schools out here that are really worth coming all the way from Iowa to pay private-school level OOS tuition except maybe computer science or engineering at UW.

We are also looking at Santa Clara University and Occidental College in California but have not visited those campuses in person. She is not planning to chase the ultra-competitive admissions schools like Stanford, USC, or Pomona that would be definite reach schools.

A few others appear to either have good merit scholarship opportunities and/or good locations for outdoor activities, plus one I just forgot yesterday:
Baylor (meant to include it yesterday - its one DD expressed interest in before I researched scholarships :slight_smile:
Arkansas
Seattle-Pacific
Maine
New Mexico
Idaho?
Libscomb (she likes the idea of Nashville, and the smaller size)
Nebraska?
Utah St?
Montana St?

For these 10 and the 11-12 in the previous post, I’m just curious if anyone has any specific experience/knowledge with any of them (related to engineering/science, scholarships, honors colleges, vibe, or anything else). We’ll research these further - not looking for y’all to do that for us - but if you happen to have something to share on any of these that’s awesome. Of these, I noticed that US News ranked UT, UF, TAMU, Ariz, Miami U, & Baylor high on “undergraduate teaching” - I’ll have to read how the rank those since that seems like a useful stat. All these rankings are a little overwhelming though - is #46 in engineering really much different than #93? Overall ranking of #200 doesn’t sound great, but they’re being ranked out of like 1500 schools, for example. My guess is at many schools you can get as good of education as you set out to, based upon your effort, and its more about finding the right “fit” at a cost you can afford.

Thanks! She does love the PNW :slight_smile: Do you happen to have any insight on Seattle-Pacific or Washington St? I believe WSU has either really good merit for NMF, ACT, or GPA.

UTDallas has merit opportunities. As does SMU, also in Dallas. Rose Hulman is a great little school.

My sis went to SPU years ago. She liked it and thought she got a great education (English). Lots to do in Seattle for sure! It’s very different than WSU. WSU is more in the plains area of Washington. google images for each just to see geographical differences.

I like reading this thread as I enjoyed researching colleges last year for my own midwest kid who wanted something new. I think being a national merit scholar will give you some additional auto merit opps that he didn’t have.

two ideas: Make a spreadsheet and keep track of what you find. And, start figuring out what you can or want to pay for school each year. Sounds like she’s doing really well- congrats!

The five that come to mind with NMF are Miami U, ASU Barrett, Arizona Honors, Kentucky Patterson and Texas A&M. My DD is going to be a freshman at Barrett in the fall and got a really good deal (full tuition OOS). It’s a big campus as you know, but Barrett makes it smaller. There are about 150 NMSF and the same # of Hispanic Recognition Program scholars, so there are a lot of bright kids there. Have heard good things about Kentucky and U of A too. Another student at her high school passed up higher ranked schools for A&M full ride.

I have also heard both Utah and Alabama also have good honors programs.

I don’t think it’s worthwhile to get into the rankings of undergraduate teaching, or number of places to eat on campus. You’ll end up with too many places on your list. Decide on 2 or 3 or 4 criteria that are most important and go from there.

Seattle Pacific is a somewhat struggling Christian college. I used to bike past it on the way to work and I have a cousin who went there. Beyond that I don’t know much about it. But I don’t think it is the type of school for a top student to come across the country for.

Washington State might be the most isolated major college in the country. Pullman will make Ames Iowa look cosmopolitan. It is right on the ID border and a LONG LONG ways from anywhere. In fact probably 2 hours from the nearest freeway.

Furman in Greenville SC meets all her criteria except distance from Iowa. Have her check it out. Furman ranks in the top 5 of all US universities for sustainability research and in the top ten for sustainability in general. They are serious about the environment. Good merit, beautiful campus, hiking/biking and kayaking available, great sciences and lots of ways to hook up with a Christian community.

How about Seattle U? It’s a large-small school, in the city, but close access to water and hiking. It’s Jesuit but socially liberal.

Expanding on my previous answer. For a top student coming from out of state to the Pacific Northwest I would summarize your options as follows.

Flagship State Schools: UW in Seattle is a cut above the rest in selectivity and resources. It is a peer with places like Michigan, UCLA, North Carolina, etc. The other three flagships, UO, OSU, and WSU are all roughly comparable in selectivity, size, and resources. UO is the favorite for OOS California students. OSU has a more local Northwest population and is more of a smaller town ag/engineering school. WSU is an oasis in far eastern WA. My daughter vetoed it immediately after we made the drive. It is really isolated and Pullman is really small. But the campus itself is beautiful and impressive.

Regional State Schools: Western Washington University in Bellingham is the only that might interest OOS students. The rest are pretty pedestrian. WWU is a gorgeous campus in Bellingham which is a gorgeous small ocean city close to Vancouver BC. It seems to be trending upwards and getting more spillover from local students who can’t get into UW-Seattle, or just want something smaller in a less urban environment.

Catholic Universities: Gonzaga, Seattle University, and University of Portland are your three choices. All roughly equivalent in size and reputation. Gonzaga is the most traditional campus across the river from downtown Spokane. Seattle University is in central Seattle a stone’s throw from the financial district so very urban. UOP is hidden away in a remote residential corner of Portland.

Liberal Arts Colleges: Reed, Whitman, Lewis & Clark, University of Puget Sound and Willamette are the five that are usually looked at most closely by OOS students. Reed and Whitman are a cut above in terms of selectivity and resources. L&C, Willamette and UPS are fairly comparable but each have their own strengths. Willamette is stronger in government, law, and management programs and the campus borders the state capitol in Salem. L&C and UPS are pretty similar with strong programs in science, international studies, and traditional liberal arts. My daughter liked the traditional English style ivy-covered quad buildings at UPS compared to the more modern campus at L&C which is sort of sprawled along a wooded hillside. But they are honestly pretty difficult to distinguish. We visited L&C on an official visit with students present. We have only been able to explore UPS ourselves as the campus is closed.

Christian Liberal Arts Colleges: There are perhaps a dozen different small Christian liberal arts colleges in the Northwest: Seattle Pacific, Pacific Lutheran, Linfield, Whitworth, George Fox, and University of Pacific are the ones I can think of off-hand. Two recently closed for financial reasons (Concordia and Marylhurst). The rest I really can’t comment on with intelligence. Although they are all a step below the five liberal arts colleges I listed above and all have smaller endowments and less resources. If I had to guess, I’d say that Pacific Lutheran, Whitworth, and Linfield are probably in the most financially sound position. But that’s just a guess.

For a top OOS student I would summarize the choices as follows of all the schools that would be of interest.

State Schools: UW > OSU, UO, WSU > WWU
Catholic Universities: Gonzaga, SU, and UOP all roughly equivalent
Liberal Arts Colleges: Reed and Whitman > Lewis & Clark, UPS, and Willamette

I don’t see much reason to come across the country for any other school in the Northwest unless you had a specific reason like a denominational affiliation or something.

DD got the impression that the majority of kids do not live on campus at UTD; does that sound accurate? Maybe that makes the school feel “smaller” like she prefers, or maybe it makes students feel disconnected??? dunno, shrug

[/quote]
Seattle Pacific is a somewhat struggling Christian college. I used to bike past it on the way to work and I have a cousin who went there. Beyond that I don’t know much about it. But I don’t think it is the type of school for a top student to come across the country for.

Washington State might be the most isolated major college in the country. Pullman will make Ames Iowa look cosmopolitan. It is right on the ID border and a LONG LONG ways from anywhere. In fact probably 2 hours from the nearest freeway.

[/quote]

@Publisher , were you agreeing about their impression of Seattle-Pacific or Pullman? Or both :wink:

Thanks! Besides sustainability, does Furman have good science programs? Looks like engineering would be done in conjunction with affiliations with Clemson or GT. Its far away, but one of her BFF’s families moved to Charlotte, and wants to study pre-law - maybe they can room together :slight_smile:

OP: Regarding your post #37 above. It is misdirected to me when I think that you meant to direct it to @Camasite (post #32 above).